“To create loving men, we must love males.”
There is a subject I find myself discussing with many of my male clients, which would be patriarchy.
I use it as one way of the many ways of helping boys and men understand themselves, their emotions, their relationships and the interpersonal dynamics they find themselves navigating. I also use it to explore something that can sometimes be overlooked in therapy: the ways in which the social, political, economic, historical and institutional worlds we inhabit influence how we think, feel and behave.
What I have noticed, however, is that many men have a difficult relationship with the word patriarchy.
For some, the word immediately brings to mind toxic masculinity. For others, their first encounter with the concept may have been through feminist discussions that felt hostile, confrontational or dismissive of men’s experiences. I want to be careful here, because I am making a generalisation. Feminism is not one thing, and women’s anger about patriarchy is not something that needs to be explained away. There are very real reasons why people become frustrated with systems that have historically restricted their opportunities, autonomy and safety.
But I do think it is worth recognising that, for some men, the word patriarchy arrives not as an invitation to understand, but as an accusation.
And when a man hears a conversation about patriarchy as a conversation about how bad men are, it becomes much harder for him to engage with what the concept might actually reveal about his own life.
This matters because patriarchy is not simply a conversation about women, nor is it simply a conversation about men behaving badly. It is a system of power. It is a way of organising social life, distributing authority, shaping expectations and establishing ideas about what men and women are supposed to be.
And those expectations can influence men in ways that are not always immediately obvious.
Patriarchy is not just something happening somewhere else
One of the things I find important in counselling is helping men recognise that understanding themselves is not exclusively an inward process.
We can spend time exploring our childhoods, our attachment patterns, our emotional responses, our relationships with our parents and the experiences that have shaped us. But we also need to consider the wider world in which those experiences took place.
What did our family teach us about being a man?
What did our culture teach us about being a woman?
What did we learn about authority, responsibility, power, vulnerability and emotional expression?
And what did we learn so early, and so repeatedly, that we no longer recognise it as something we learned at all?
In British society and across Reading and Berkshire, many of these ideas are so deeply embedded that they can be difficult to see. They are present in our language, our stories, our institutions, our family structures and our everyday assumptions.
In some ways, patriarchy can be a little like air. We may not notice the system around us until we begin to struggle to breathe within it.
For some men, that moment comes during a crisis. It might be a relationship breakdown, the loss of a job, becoming a father, experiencing emotional distress or realising that the ways they have learned to manage their feelings are no longer working.
But I would argue that men should not have to wait until they are in crisis before exploring their masculinity.
We do not have to wait until we are struggling to ask ourselves what it means to be a man, how we have learned to express emotion, or whether the expectations we have inherited are helping us live the lives we want to live.
Bell hooks: patriarchy and the emotional lives of men
One book I often think about when exploring these questions is The Will to Change: Men, Masculinity, and Love by bell hooks. Hooks offers a particularly important starting point for men who want to understand patriarchy without reducing the conversation to whether men are good or bad.
She defines patriarchy as a “political-social system” that establishes male dominance and legitimises the domination of those considered weaker. The full definition is deliberately confronting. It asks us to look beyond individual intentions and consider how power is organised, normalised and reproduced.
What I find especially important in hooks’ work is that she does not only examine how patriarchy shapes men’s relationships with women. She also examines how it shapes men’s relationships with themselves.
Men may be taught that emotional vulnerability is weakness, that they should be self-sufficient, that they should not need help, or that their value is connected to their ability to provide, protect, achieve or maintain control.
These expectations can have consequences.
A man may struggle to communicate that he is frightened because he has learned that fear is incompatible with masculinity. He may find it difficult to ask for support because he has been taught that needing help makes him inadequate. He may struggle to express sadness, not because he does not experience it, but because he has never been given the language or permission to do so.
hooks makes a particularly powerful argument about the emotional conditioning of boys. Patriarchal culture can teach boys to disconnect from feelings that are considered incompatible with masculinity. This is not simply about telling a boy not to cry. It can involve teaching him, through repeated interactions, that certain parts of himself are unacceptable.
The boy who is told to stop crying may learn that sadness is embarrassing.
The boy who is mocked for being frightened may learn that fear should be hidden.
The boy who is praised only when he is tough, successful or useful may begin to believe that love must be earned through performance.
And the boy who is repeatedly told to “man up” may eventually stop asking himself what he is actually feeling.
This is one of the reasons I think hooks’ work is so valuable in counselling. It invites us to consider not only what a man is experiencing, but what he may have learned about the acceptability of experiencing it.
The difference between masculinity and patriarchal masculinity
I think it is important to make a distinction between masculinity itself and the particular forms of masculinity that are privileged within patriarchal systems.
Masculinity is not one fixed identity. There are many ways of being a man. Men differ in their cultures, sexuality, class, race, faith, family experiences, personalities and relationships. Even within the same community, men may have very different understandings of what it means to be masculine.
Sociologist Raewyn Connell’s concept of hegemonic masculinity is useful here. It describes the culturally privileged form of masculinity that helps sustain gender inequality. It is not necessarily the masculinity practised by every man, or even most men. Rather, it is an ideal that can establish which men are respected, which men are marginalised, and which qualities are treated as desirable or inferior.
This means patriarchy does not only organise power between men and women. It can also organise power between men.
Consider the man who is judged because he is not physically strong, financially successful, sexually confident, heterosexual, emotionally detached or dominant.
He may experience himself as failing at masculinity, even if he has never consciously agreed with the standards by which he is being judged.
A gay man may be told that he is not masculine enough. A man who earns less than his partner may feel that he has failed as a provider. A man who is emotionally expressive may be mocked by other men. A man who does not want children may feel that he has failed to fulfil an expected life role.
The point is not that all men experience these pressures equally. They do not. The point is that masculinity can become a hierarchy, with some ways of being a man valued more highly than others.
And this hierarchy can have psychological consequences.
A man may spend years trying to prove that he belongs within a particular version of masculinity, without ever asking whether that version of masculinity is actually helping him live a meaningful life.
The stories we inherit
Recently, I was exploring mythology, fairy tales and cultural stories about motherhood with a client.
We began asking questions about what the client had learned about motherhood. What is a mother supposed to be? What is her role? How does that role relate to fatherhood? How were these expectations shaped by the way the client had been parented? And how might they influence the kind of father the client wants to become?
We also explored how the roles of mother and father might complement one another in raising a child.
The client had never really considered these questions before.
This is one of the things I find fascinating about therapeutic work. We can spend our entire lives surrounded by ideas without ever consciously examining them.
Think about that expression Mother Nature. Why do we describe nature using the language of motherhood? What does that association suggest about our ideas of women, nurturing, creation and care?
Or consider the stories we tell about fathers. What do they teach us about authority, protection, discipline, provision and emotional presence?
These associations are not necessarily random. They emerge from histories, cultures, traditions and ways of understanding the world. And because they are repeated so frequently, they can begin to feel natural.
But something feeling natural does not necessarily mean it is inevitable, universal or beyond question.
The language we use and the stories we inherit can create presuppositions, expectations and assumptions about how people should behave. Those expectations can influence how we understand ourselves, how we relate to others and what we believe is possible for us.
In therapy, we can begin to explore those assumptions. Not simply to reject them, but to understand where they came from, what purpose they serve and whether they still make sense in our lives.
The family is one of the places where systems become personal
When we talk about patriarchy, it can be tempting to think only about governments, laws, workplaces or political institutions. But systems also become personal through everyday family life.
A child does not need to understand the word patriarchy to learn its rules.
He may learn that his father makes the final decisions. He may learn that his mother is responsible for the emotional atmosphere of the household. He may learn that boys should be brave and girls should be caring. He may learn that a father’s job is to provide financially while a mother’s job is to provide emotionally.
These lessons can be communicated explicitly, through what parents say, or implicitly, through what children observe.
A boy may watch his father return from work exhausted, emotionally withdrawn and unable to speak about his day. He may observe his mother taking responsibility for the family’s emotional needs. He may learn that a man’s contribution is measured by what he earns, while a woman’s contribution is measured by what she does for others.
None of these observations automatically determines how that boy will live. But they may become part of the template through which he understands relationships.
When he becomes a partner or father himself, he may find himself repeating familiar patterns without consciously choosing them.
Or he may do the opposite.
He may decide that he will never be like his father. He may reject traditional masculinity altogether. But even then, he may still be organising his identity around the same inherited model, simply in opposition to it.
As hooks observes in The Will to Change, reacting against a father’s behaviour is not necessarily the same as developing a conscious alternative. We can spend our lives trying not to become someone else without fully discovering who we want to be.
This is a particularly useful question in counselling: Am I choosing how I want to live, or am I still reacting to the life I was given?
The emotional cost of being a man who cannot ask for help
One of the most important areas in which these ideas become visible is mental health.
The World Health Organization’s European review on men, masculinity and mental health identified self-reliance, difficulty expressing emotions and expectations of self-control as important sociocultural barriers to men seeking psychological help. It also highlighted wider pressures, including economic insecurity and limited access to services, and noted that trusted relationships and communities can help men seek support.
This matters because the instruction to be self-reliant can sound positive.
We want boys and men to develop independence, confidence, responsibility and the ability to manage difficult situations. These can be valuable qualities.
But self-reliance becomes restrictive when it means that a man believes he must face every difficulty alone.
There is a difference between being capable of managing your life and believing that needing help makes you weak.
There is a difference between emotional regulation and emotional suppression.
There is a difference between being resilient and being unable to acknowledge that something has hurt you.
And there is a difference between being independent and being isolated.
The American Psychological Association’s guidelines for psychological practice with boys and men similarly recognise that some masculine norms can have negative consequences for psychological health, while also acknowledging that qualities commonly associated with masculinity, such as courage, compassion, leadership and assertiveness, can be positive.
This is an important distinction. The goal is not to persuade men to abandon every quality associated with masculinity. The goal is to help them examine which qualities are serving them, which are restricting them, and how they might develop a more flexible and integrated sense of self.
A man can be courageous and vulnerable.
He can be independent and ask for help.
He can be strong and acknowledge pain.
He can be a father who provides financially and a father who is emotionally present.
These are not contradictions. They are possibilities.
Anger, silence and the emotions men are permitted to express
I also think we need to explore the way anger can become one of the few emotions that men feel permitted to express.
Anger is not inherently a destructive emotion. It can communicate that something is unfair, that a boundary has been crossed, or that a person is experiencing frustration or threat.
But in some contexts, anger may become a more acceptable expression of distress than sadness, fear, shame or grief.
A man who cannot say, “I feel rejected,” may say, “I’m angry.”
A man who cannot say, “I am frightened that I am going to lose my family,” may become controlling.
A man who cannot say, “I feel inadequate,” may become defensive or dismissive.
These are not universal explanations for anger, and they should not be used to excuse aggression or abuse. But they can offer a useful avenue for therapeutic exploration.
What is the anger communicating?
What happened immediately before it?
What does the person believe the situation means about them?
What other emotions might be present?
And what has the person learned about whether those emotions are acceptable to express?
hooks writes about the way patriarchal culture can legitimise anger in men while discouraging other forms of emotional expression. Her work invites us to consider how emotional restriction can affect intimacy, connection and the capacity to love.
This is not simply an individual emotional skills issue. It is also a question about the social conditions in which those skills are developed, encouraged or discouraged.
Patriarchy, love and the performance of being a man
One of the ideas I find most powerful in hooks’ work is her exploration of the relationship between masculinity and love.
Many men are taught to demonstrate love through provision, protection, problem-solving and sacrifice. These can be meaningful expressions of care. But they can become restrictive when they are treated as the only acceptable expressions of love.
A man may believe that because he works hard, pays the bills and protects his family, he is fulfilling his role as a partner or father.
And yet his partner may be asking for something else: emotional presence, shared responsibility, curiosity, tenderness, communication or the ability to talk about difficult feelings.
This does not necessarily mean that one person is right and the other is wrong. It may mean that they have inherited different ideas about what love looks like.
The therapeutic task is not to dismiss the man’s understanding of love, but to explore it.
Where did he learn that providing is the primary expression of love?
What did he observe in his own family?
What does he believe a man is supposed to do when his partner is upset?
Does he understand emotional presence as a form of responsibility?
Can he recognise the difference between solving a problem and being emotionally available to someone who is experiencing it?
And can he learn to express love in ways that are meaningful to both himself and the people he cares about?
hooks argues that men’s capacity to love is not separate from their capacity to challenge patriarchal expectations. Her work calls for men to reclaim emotional expression and connection, rather than treating vulnerability as a threat to masculinity.
I think this is an especially important conversation for men who want to become fathers.
What does it mean to raise a boy who knows that he is loved when he is successful, but also when he is struggling?
What does it mean to raise a girl who understands that love does not require her to accept emotional absence or domination?
What does it mean to raise children who can experience their fathers as emotionally available, rather than only as providers or authority figures?
These are not simply questions about parenting styles. They are questions about the kind of emotional culture we want to create within our families.
The therapeutic value of examining inherited beliefs
In counselling, I often find that men have not consciously chosen many of the expectations they hold about themselves.
They may believe that they should be financially successful by a certain age, that they should be able to manage their emotions independently, that they should always know what to do, or that they should not need reassurance.
Some of these beliefs may motivate them. Others may contribute to anxiety, shame, relationship difficulties or a persistent sense of inadequacy.
The work is not necessarily to tell a client that these beliefs are wrong.
Instead, we can become curious about them.
Where did this belief come from?
Who taught it to you?
What happens when you do not meet that expectation?
What does it mean about you if you cannot fulfil it?
Does this belief reflect your own values, or does it reflect an expectation you have inherited?
What might change if you gave yourself permission to question it?
These questions can help a client begin to distinguish between their own values and the social expectations they have absorbed.
They can also help us recognise that the client’s difficulties may not be solely the result of an individual psychological problem. His distress may be connected to a conflict between his needs, his values, his circumstances and the expectations placed upon him.
That does not mean that social explanations replace psychological ones. It means that they can add another layer of understanding.
A man may be experiencing anxiety because of a particular thought pattern. He may also be experiencing anxiety because he believes that his worth depends on being successful, strong or financially secure.
Both levels deserve attention.
Understanding without excusing
I think one of the most important parts of this conversation is the distinction between understanding a system and excusing behaviour.
A man may have been taught to suppress his emotions. That can help us understand why emotional expression is difficult for him.
It does not make it acceptable for him to intimidate his partner.
A man may have learned that control is part of being masculine. That can help us understand why he struggles with uncertainty.
It does not justify controlling another person.
A man may have grown up in a household where violence was normalised. That may be important to understanding his history.
It does not remove his responsibility for the choices he makes as an adult.
Understanding can create the conditions for accountability. It can help us move beyond simplistic explanations and consider what needs to change.
It is possible to hold compassion for a man’s history while remaining clear about the impact of his behaviour.
It is possible to acknowledge that men can be harmed by patriarchal expectations while recognising that women and children can experience the consequences of male power and domination in profoundly different ways.
And it is possible to invite men into this conversation without asking women to carry the responsibility for their emotional development.
This is where I think hooks’ work is particularly valuable. It asks us to recognise the ways patriarchy can damage men while remaining clear that this damage does not erase the inequalities and harms that patriarchy produces.
A conversation worth having before crisis
One of the things I want to encourage boys and men to do is to explore their masculinity before they find themselves in crisis.
It is worth asking:
What have I learned about being a man?
What am I allowed to feel?
What happens when I cry?
What do I believe a good father should be?
What do I believe a good partner should be?
Where did those beliefs come from?
What do I believe I must achieve in order to be worthy of love and respect?
How do I respond when someone challenges my understanding of masculinity?
And are the expectations I have inherited helping me become the man I want to be?
These are not always easy questions. They can be confronting, particularly when the answers challenge ideas that have been part of our lives for decades.
But they are important questions.
Because understanding ourselves is not only about understanding our inner world. It is also about understanding the worlds that helped create it.
And sometimes, the most meaningful work we can do is to begin examining the things we have always assumed were simply the way life is.
Therapy can be a place to examine the “rules” of masculinity
This is how we might explore masculinity with a client.
For example:
- “What does being a good man mean to you?”
- “What happens when you feel you are not meeting that standard?”
- “Who taught you that this was what a man should do?”
- “What would you think of another man who behaved differently?”
- “Would you want your son to inherit this expectation?”
- “What parts of this belief do you want to keep?”
- “What parts might you want to change?”
This approach avoids assuming that the therapist already knows what masculinity means to the client. It also gives the client room to identify what he values about masculinity, rather than simply being asked to reject it.
Suggested reading list for men in Reading
The Will to Change: Men, Masculinity, and Love (2004)
Patriarchy, male emotional life, love and the possibility of change
Raewyn Connell
Masculinities (1995; revised editions available)
Multiple masculinities, gender hierarchy and hegemonic masculinity
Connell and Messerschmidt
‘Hegemonic masculinity: Rethinking the concept’ (2005)
A foundational revision of hegemonic masculinity theory
Michael Kimmel
Manhood in America: A Cultural History (1996; later editions)
The historical and cultural construction of American masculinity
Terry Real
I Don’t Want to Talk About It: Overcoming the Secret Legacy of Male Depression (1997)
Male depression, emotional restriction and relational patterns
World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe
Mental health, men and culture (2020)
Masculinity norms and men’s mental health help-seeking
American Psychological Association
Guidelines for Psychological Practice with Boys and Men (2018)
Research-informed and strength-based psychological practice
