There is a philosophical conversation I sometimes have with my clients in therapy. It is a conversation that can be uncomfortable, particularly in a world that seems to have an answer for everything. The conversation is this: Not everything can be fixed. Not everything can be healed. Not everything can be overcome.
I know that might sound pessimistic. It might even sound like the opposite of what we have come to expect from counselling, psychotherapy and personal development.
Men in Reading are constantly being told that we can change our lives. That we can overcome our past. That we can heal our trauma. That we can achieve our goals. That we can become the person we have always wanted to be.
And there is truth in that.
I have seen men change their lives in ways they once thought were impossible. I have seen men recover from addiction, rebuild relationships, develop a greater understanding of themselves and begin to live in ways that would have seemed unimaginable to them a few years earlier.
I have seen men who believed they were incapable of love begin to develop meaningful relationships.
I have seen men who believed they would always be controlled by their anger begin to understand their emotional experiences.
I have seen men who believed their childhood had determined the rest of their lives begin to recognise that they still have choices.
And I have seen men who have spent years believing that they are fundamentally broken begin to develop a different relationship with themselves.
So I believe in change. I believe in the power of love. I believe in the importance of choice. I believe in the value of discipline, perseverance, courage and personal responsibility.
But I also believe that there is a point at which we need to have a different conversation. Because what happens when somebody has done everything they possibly can, and the situation still does not change?
What happens when somebody has loved another person with everything they have, and that person still dies?
What happens when somebody has spent years trying to recover from addiction, and the struggle remains part of their life?
What happens when somebody has done everything they have been told to do to achieve success, and they still cannot seem to get there?
What happens when a person has experienced something so devastating that the idea of returning to the person they were before no longer makes sense?
And what happens when we begin to recognise that some of the things we experience in life are not problems that can be solved?
Perhaps they are experiences that we have to learn to live with.
I think this is an important conversation for men in Reading, Berkshire, and the surrounding towns and villages. Because there are men who are struggling with things they cannot change.
There are men who are carrying grief. There are men who are living with addiction. There are men who are trying to make sense of difficult childhoods. There are men who have lost relationships, children, careers, health or opportunities.
And there are men who have spent so much of their lives trying to overcome their difficulties that they have begun to believe that if they are still struggling, they must be doing something wrong.
Perhaps they need to try harder.
Perhaps they need more discipline.
Perhaps they need to change their mindset.
Perhaps they need to stop making excuses.
Perhaps they need to become stronger.
But what if the problem is not that they have failed to overcome something?
What if the problem is that they have been taught to believe that everything must be overcome in the first place?
The problem with telling people that everything is possible
One of the things I find interesting about modern personal development is the way we have come to understand suffering.
We have developed an entire language around overcoming.
Overcoming adversity.
Overcoming trauma.
Overcoming addiction.
Overcoming your past.
Overcoming your circumstances.
And again, there is nothing inherently wrong with this language. Sometimes, it is exactly what a person needs to hear.
A man who has experienced a difficult childhood may need to hear that his childhood does not determine his future.
A man who has struggled with addiction may need to hear that recovery is possible.
A man who has lost his confidence may need to hear that he can develop it.
A man who has been rejected may need to hear that rejection does not make him unlovable.
But I wonder whether, somewhere along the way, we have created another problem.
What happens when the language of overcoming becomes an expectation?
What happens when a person begins to believe that if they have not overcome their difficulties, they must not be trying hard enough?
What happens when the person who has been told that they can achieve anything begins to feel ashamed because they cannot achieve the thing they want most?
I think we need to be careful.
Because there is a difference between telling somebody that change is possible and telling them that every outcome is within their control.
The first can offer hope.
The second can create shame.
And for some people, that shame can become another burden they have to carry.
Imagine a man who has spent years trying to recover from addiction.
He has attended treatment.
He has worked with counsellors.
He has tried to change his environment.
He has developed coping strategies.
He has attempted to rebuild his relationships.
And he is still struggling.
What happens if he begins to believe that his continued struggle is evidence of a personal failure?
What happens if he starts to believe that other people have recovered because they were stronger, more disciplined or more deserving than he is?
What happens if he begins to feel that he has failed at recovery itself?
This is where we need to distinguish between the possibility of change and the expectation of perfect change.
Recovery is possible.
But recovery does not always follow a straight line.
And a person’s worth cannot be measured by whether they have achieved the outcome they hoped for.
The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism describes recovery as a dynamic, individualised process. Its guidance recognises that recovery pathways vary, and that improvements in health, relationships and wellbeing may occur alongside changes in drinking behaviour.
That is important.
Because sometimes, the question is not whether a person has overcome their difficulty completely.
Sometimes, the question is whether their life has become more manageable, more meaningful or more connected, even while the difficulty remains.
And sometimes, we need to recognise that progress and perfection are not the same thing.
Love is powerful. But love cannot do everything.
I believe in love. I have seen the difference it can make in people’s lives.
Many of the men I work with have told me that the reason they began to change was because they met somebody who believed in them.
Sometimes, it was a partner.
Sometimes, it was a best friend.
Sometimes, it was a brother.
Sometimes, it was a coach who recognised something in them that they had not yet recognised in themselves.
A man who had spent years believing that he was worthless met somebody who treated him as though he mattered.
A man who had been told that he would never amount to anything met somebody who believed he could succeed.
A man who had experienced betrayal met somebody who demonstrated that trust was still possible.
And a man who had grown up believing that love had to be earned met somebody who offered him affection without requiring him to perform.
These experiences can be transformative.
Love can provide safety.
Love can create belonging.
Love can motivate change.
Love can help us imagine a different future.
And love can give us the courage to attempt things we might otherwise have avoided.
But there is something I think we need to acknowledge.
Love cannot guarantee an outcome.
You can love somebody with everything you have and still lose them.
You can love a person struggling with addiction and still be unable to prevent their death.
You can love a partner who is experiencing severe mental health difficulties and still be unable to remove their suffering.
You can love your child and still be unable to protect them from every experience that will hurt them.
You can love your father and still have to accept that he may never become the father you needed.
And you can love somebody who does not love you back.
This is not an argument against love.
It is an argument for understanding its limits.
Because if we believe that love can overcome everything, we may begin to blame ourselves when it does not.
A mother might believe that if she had loved her son more, he would not have died from addiction.
A man might believe that if he had been a better partner, his relationship would not have ended.
A person might believe that if they had been more patient, more understanding or more forgiving, the other person would have changed.
But sometimes, another person’s circumstances, decisions, behaviour or difficulties are beyond our control.
And sometimes, the most painful thing we have to learn is that loving somebody does not mean we can save them.
There is a difference between loving somebody and being responsible for the outcome of their life.
And there is a difference between offering support and believing that we must be able to prevent every tragedy.
Perhaps one of the most important things we can learn about love is that it can be profoundly meaningful without being all-powerful.
The power of will, choice and discipline
There is another conversation I often have with clients about the power of the human will.
Somebody once expressed the idea that nothing can resist the human will when it is prepared to stake its existence on a single purpose.
The sentiment is powerful.
When somebody decides that they are going to do something, it can appear as though nothing will get in their way.
We see this in people who recover from addiction.
We see it in people who rebuild their lives after difficult experiences.
We see it in people who train for years to achieve something extraordinary.
We see it in people who continue working towards a goal despite repeated disappointment.
And we see it in men who have experienced adversity and refuse to allow their circumstances to define the rest of their lives.
There is something admirable about that determination.
But I think we need to distinguish between the power of the will and the fantasy of total control.
Because we can choose how we respond to some experiences.
We cannot choose every experience that happens to us.
We can develop discipline.
We cannot guarantee every outcome.
We can work hard.
We cannot guarantee success.
We can make choices.
We cannot guarantee that those choices will produce the results we want.
And this is where I think we need to be careful with the language of personal responsibility.
Personal responsibility matters.
But responsibility is not the same as omnipotence.
A man can be responsible for his decisions without being responsible for every circumstance that affects his life.
A woman can make courageous choices without being able to guarantee her safety.
A person can work hard without being able to overcome every disadvantage.
And a person can do everything they reasonably can to improve their situation and still experience disappointment.
That is not necessarily a failure of character.
Sometimes, it is simply the reality of being human.
The uncomfortable reality of luck
Consider two people who begin a YouTube channel.
They both research their audience.
They both create interesting content.
They both post consistently.
They both learn about thumbnails, titles, editing and audience retention.
One of them begins to attract thousands of subscribers.
The other struggles to reach a few thousand after months of work.
Now imagine that the first person begins to tell the world that their success is entirely the result of discipline, consistency and mindset.
And imagine that the second person begins to believe that their lack of success is entirely the result of insufficient effort.
Both conclusions may be incomplete.
Because success is influenced by more than effort.
It can be influenced by timing, social networks, access to resources, audience preferences, competition, algorithms, opportunity and chance.
The same is true of many other areas of life.
Two people can make similar decisions and experience very different outcomes.
Two people can work equally hard and achieve different levels of success.
Two people can experience similar difficulties and respond in different ways.
And two people can make the same mistake and experience very different consequences.
This does not mean that effort is irrelevant.
It means that effort is not the only variable.
And perhaps we need to become more comfortable acknowledging that.
Because when we attribute every success to personal virtue and every failure to personal weakness, we create a world in which people who are struggling are automatically assumed to have done something wrong.
That is not wisdom.
It is a misunderstanding of how life works.
Some people carry a burden that does not disappear
I believe that every person has something in their life that they may have to learn to carry.
For some people, it is a physical condition.
For others, it is a psychological difficulty.
For some, it is an experience of loss.
For others, it is a relationship that can never become what they hoped it would be.
And for some, it is the reality that the life they imagined for themselves may never become the life they actually live.
I want to be careful with this idea, because I am not suggesting that every person has a permanent burden, or that people should simply accept suffering that can be treated, prevented or reduced.
There are many circumstances in which intervention, support, treatment and social change can make an enormous difference.
But there are also circumstances in which the difficulty remains.
A person may live with chronic pain.
A person may experience recurrent depression.
A person may struggle with addiction.
A person may have a lifelong disability.
A person may experience a form of grief that never entirely disappears.
A person may never have the relationship with their parents that they wanted.
And a person may spend years trying to understand an aspect of their identity that remains complicated.
The question is not necessarily whether these experiences can be removed.
Sometimes, the question is how a person can build a meaningful life alongside them.
This is an important distinction in psychotherapy.
Because if we define healing exclusively as the removal of suffering, we risk creating an expectation that is neither realistic nor compassionate.
We may begin to believe that a person has not healed because they still experience sadness.
That a person has not recovered because they still experience cravings.
That a person has not moved on because they still miss somebody.
That a person has not accepted themselves because they continue to struggle with aspects of their identity.
But perhaps we need a more nuanced understanding of what healing can look like.
Perhaps healing can involve becoming less frightened of our own emotions.
Perhaps it can involve developing a better understanding of our experiences.
Perhaps it can involve learning how to manage a condition that remains part of our lives.
Perhaps it can involve recognising that we can experience pain without allowing that pain to determine every decision we make.
And perhaps it can involve learning to live with the things that cannot be changed.
The psychology of acceptance: Learning to live with what is
One of the therapeutic approaches that I think is particularly relevant to this conversation is Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, commonly known as ACT.
ACT is based on the idea that psychological wellbeing does not necessarily require the elimination of difficult thoughts and feelings.
Instead, it emphasises psychological flexibility.
This involves being able to experience difficult internal experiences while continuing to engage in actions that are meaningful and consistent with our values.
In other words, we do not necessarily have to wait until we feel better before we begin to live.
A person experiencing anxiety can still build relationships.
A person experiencing grief can still experience moments of joy.
A person living with chronic pain can still engage in meaningful activities.
A person who has experienced trauma can still develop a sense of safety and connection.
And a person who continues to struggle with addiction can still work towards a life that reflects their values.
Research into ACT for chronic pain has found that the approach can improve pain acceptance, psychological flexibility and aspects of psychological functioning, although the effects vary across outcomes and studies. A 2024 systematic review and meta-analysis included 21 randomised controlled trials and found improvements in several measures, including pain interference, functional impairment and depression.
This is important because it challenges the idea that a person’s life must remain on hold until their suffering disappears.
But acceptance is often misunderstood.
Acceptance does not mean approving of what happened.
It does not mean that we should stop trying to improve our circumstances.
It does not mean that we should remain in abusive relationships.
It does not mean that we should stop seeking treatment.
And it does not mean that we should accept injustice.
Acceptance is about recognising the reality of our present circumstances without allowing the struggle against that reality to consume all of our psychological energy.
There is a difference between accepting that something happened and believing that it should have happened.
There is a difference between accepting that a person has died and believing that their death was acceptable.
There is a difference between accepting that a relationship has ended and believing that the relationship did not matter.
And there is a difference between accepting that we have a condition and believing that we are defined by it.
Sometimes, acceptance is not the end of our efforts to change.
It is the beginning of a more realistic relationship with what we can and cannot change.
The philosophy of suffering: What the darker thinkers understood
I think this conversation becomes particularly interesting when we begin to explore philosophy.
Because the idea that suffering is an unavoidable part of human existence is not new.
It has been explored by philosophers, writers, theologians and psychologists for centuries.
Arthur Schopenhauer, for example, developed a philosophy in which human existence is characterised by desire, dissatisfaction and suffering.
His argument was that much of our suffering emerges from the fact that we are continually striving for things that cannot provide lasting satisfaction.
We want something.
We pursue it.
We obtain it.
And then we begin wanting something else.
Or we fail to obtain it and experience disappointment.
This does not mean that all desire is bad, or that human life is necessarily meaningless.
But Schopenhauer challenges the assumption that happiness can be achieved simply by obtaining everything we want.
There is something worth considering here.
Because we live in a culture that frequently tells us that the solution to dissatisfaction is more.
More money.
More success.
More attention.
More achievement.
More validation.
More experiences.
More possessions.
And yet, some people spend their entire lives pursuing these things without ever experiencing the sense of peace they imagined they would provide.
Perhaps the problem is not always that they have failed to achieve enough.
Perhaps the problem is that they have placed their expectation of happiness entirely on achieving something external.
Nietzsche and the burden of becoming
Friedrich Nietzsche is another philosopher worth considering.
His work is often associated with the idea of overcoming, but I think it is important not to reduce his philosophy to a motivational slogan.
Nietzsche explored the relationship between suffering, meaning, personal transformation and the development of the self.
He challenged the idea that suffering must always be understood as something that diminishes us.
But he also recognised that suffering does not automatically produce growth.
A person can experience suffering and become more compassionate.
A person can experience suffering and become more bitter.
A person can experience suffering and develop a deeper understanding of themselves.
A person can experience suffering and become overwhelmed by it.
The experience itself does not guarantee a particular outcome.
And this is where I think Nietzsche is particularly relevant to the conversation about men.
Because we often tell men that adversity will make them stronger.
But sometimes, adversity makes people more vulnerable.
Sometimes, it leaves them with difficulties that require support.
Sometimes, it changes their lives in ways they never wanted.
And sometimes, the most important thing we can do is not to demand that they turn their suffering into a success story.
Perhaps we need to allow people to acknowledge that something hurt them.
Perhaps we need to recognise that they do not have to become extraordinary because they have suffered.
Perhaps they do not need to transform every painful experience into a lesson.
And perhaps they are allowed to grieve the fact that something happened to them that they never wanted.
Camus and the possibility of living without an answer
Albert Camus offers another perspective.
In his exploration of the absurd, Camus considered the tension between our desire for meaning and the world’s apparent indifference to that desire.
We want answers.
We want explanations.
We want to believe that suffering has a purpose.
We want to believe that everything happens for a reason.
But what happens when we cannot find one?
What happens when somebody dies and there is no explanation that makes their death acceptable?
What happens when a child experiences abuse?
What happens when a person loses their home?
What happens when somebody spends years trying to change their circumstances and nothing improves?
Camus does not offer us a simple answer.
Instead, his philosophy explores the possibility of living with the reality that the world may not provide the explanations we seek.
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes Camus’s response to the absurd in terms of lucid awareness, refusal to submit and continuing to live with vitality despite the absence of ultimate answers.
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
I find this particularly interesting because it challenges the idea that we must understand everything before we can begin to live.
Perhaps we do not need to know why something happened.
Perhaps we do not need to believe that every experience has a purpose.
Perhaps we do not need to turn every loss into a lesson.
Perhaps we can acknowledge that something terrible happened and still find reasons to continue living.
Not because the suffering was justified.
Not because it made us stronger.
But because our lives still have value.
And perhaps that is enough.
The reality of suffering: Some people cannot simply change their circumstances
I think we sometimes forget how different people’s lives can be.
We can spend so much time discussing personal development, mindset, discipline and emotional regulation that we begin to assume that everybody has the same opportunities to change their circumstances.
But they do not.
There are people living in countries where armed conflict has become part of everyday life.
There are families who have spent years moving between temporary shelters.
There are children who have grown up hearing explosions.
There are parents who are trying to raise children while worrying about whether they will have food, clean water or somewhere safe to sleep.
There are people who want to leave their countries but cannot obtain the necessary documents or find a safe route to do so.
There are people who want to access healthcare but cannot afford it.
There are people who want to leave abusive relationships but face financial, social or physical barriers.
And there are people who have spent years trying to change circumstances that are not entirely within their control.
I think it is important to recognise these realities because they challenge the idea that suffering can always be overcome through individual effort.
Imagine telling a person who has been displaced by war that they simply need to change their mindset.
Imagine telling a person who cannot afford housing that they need to become more disciplined.
Imagine telling a person who is living under an abusive regime that they need to take responsibility for their circumstances.
Imagine telling a child who has experienced sexual violence that they need to become more resilient.
These statements may sound like encouragement.
But they can also demonstrate a profound misunderstanding of the circumstances in which people live.
Because there are situations in which the problem is not the individual’s mindset.
The problem is the environment.
And sometimes, the most important work is not helping a person adapt to that environment.
It is changing the environment itself.
This is particularly important when we consider issues such as poverty, discrimination, violence, access to healthcare and the availability of social support.
We cannot simply individualise every form of suffering.
Some difficulties are personal.
Some are relational.
Some are structural.
And many involve a combination of all three.
A person’s psychological wellbeing is shaped not only by their internal world, but also by the conditions in which they live.
This is why I think the conversation about acceptance must always be accompanied by a conversation about justice.
Because acceptance should never become an excuse for allowing preventable suffering to continue.
The woman who cannot safely leave
There is another example that I think is particularly important.
Domestic abuse.
We often tell people who are experiencing abuse that they need to leave.
And sometimes, leaving is an important step towards safety.
But the reality is more complicated.
A woman who is experiencing abuse may be financially dependent on her partner.
She may have children.
She may have nowhere to go.
She may fear that leaving will result in further violence.
She may be isolated from friends and family.
She may have experienced threats.
She may be living with a partner who monitors her movements, communications or finances.
And she may have attempted to leave before.
The UK government’s statutory guidance on controlling or coercive behaviour recognises that abuse can continue after a relationship ends, and that the post-separation period can carry significant risks for victims and children.
Research examining domestic homicide reviews in England and Wales has identified separation, stalking and the victim entering a new relationship among the risk factors associated with intimate partner homicide.
This does not mean that leaving is always more dangerous than staying, or that a person should remain in an abusive relationship.
It means that leaving can require careful safety planning and specialist support.
And it means that we need to be careful about telling people that they simply need to make a choice.
Because sometimes, the choice is not straightforward.
Sometimes, the person knows what they want to do.
Sometimes, they have tried.
Sometimes, they are frightened.
Sometimes, they are trying to protect their children.
And sometimes, they are doing the best they can within circumstances that are genuinely dangerous.
This is where the language of personal responsibility can become particularly damaging.
Because we may begin to judge somebody for not leaving without understanding what leaving might mean for them.
We may assume that they are choosing to remain in an abusive relationship.
When, in reality, they may be trying to survive.
And perhaps this is another example of why we need to recognise that not every problem can be solved through willpower alone.
Sometimes, people need resources.
Sometimes, they need practical support.
Sometimes, they need protection.
Sometimes, they need a safe place to go.
And sometimes, they need somebody to understand that their situation is more complicated than it appears.
Addiction: When love, willpower and resources are still not enough
I want to return to addiction because I think it illustrates the limits of the language of overcoming particularly well.
There are people who have struggled with addiction for years.
They have tried to stop.
They have attended treatment.
They have sought support.
They have made promises to themselves and to others.
They have experienced periods of recovery.
They have experienced setbacks.
And they may continue to struggle.
For the families of people experiencing addiction, this can be particularly painful.
A parent might spend years trying to help their child.
They might pay for treatment.
They might attend support groups.
They might contact services.
They might attempt to establish boundaries.
They might try to understand the condition.
They might pray.
They might hope.
And sometimes, despite everything they do, their child dies.
I think we need to be able to talk about this without immediately trying to turn it into a story about resilience.
Because sometimes, the person who dies does not get to experience recovery.
Sometimes, the family does not get the ending they hoped for.
Sometimes, love is not enough to prevent a tragedy.
And sometimes, the people who survive are left with questions that cannot be answered.
Why did this happen?
Could I have done more?
Did I miss something?
Was there another treatment?
Should I have intervened earlier?
Should I have been stricter?
Should I have been more understanding?
These questions can become a source of profound guilt.
But addiction is not simply a failure of willpower.
It involves complex interactions between biological, psychological and social factors.
The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism describes alcohol use disorder as a condition with varied pathways to recovery, and notes that the majority of people with alcohol use disorder reduce or resolve their drinking problems over time.
That is an important message of hope.
But it does not mean that every person recovers in the same way, or that every person will survive their addiction.
And it does not mean that families are responsible for preventing every possible outcome.
We can recognise the possibility of recovery while acknowledging the reality of loss.
We can support people who are struggling without pretending that the outcome is guaranteed.
And we can recognise that a family may have done everything reasonably possible and still experience a devastating loss.
This is not a failure of love.
It is the reality of a condition that can be profoundly difficult to manage.
The difference between giving up and accepting reality
I think one of the reasons this conversation can be difficult is because we are afraid that if we acknowledge the limits of change, people will give up.
We worry that if we tell somebody that not everything can be overcome, they will stop trying.
We worry that if we encourage acceptance, they will become passive.
We worry that if we acknowledge the possibility of permanent difficulties, we will take away their hope.
But I think we need to distinguish between two very different things.
Giving up on ourselves.
And giving up on the fantasy that we can control everything.
They are not the same.
A man who accepts that he has a chronic health condition is not necessarily giving up on his health.
He may be learning how to manage it.
A man who accepts that his father will never become emotionally available is not necessarily giving up on relationships.
He may be learning how to develop healthier relationships with other people.
A man who accepts that a relationship has ended is not necessarily giving up on love.
He may be making room for a different future.
A man who accepts that he continues to experience difficult emotions is not necessarily giving up on his mental health.
He may be learning how to live with those emotions without allowing them to determine every aspect of his life.
And a man who accepts that he cannot change the past is not necessarily giving up on himself.
He may be beginning to recognise that the future is still available to him.
This is where I think acceptance can become a form of courage.
Because sometimes, it takes more courage to acknowledge the reality of a situation than it does to continue pretending that everything will eventually become what we want it to be.
Sometimes, we need to stop fighting the fact that something happened.
Sometimes, we need to stop waiting for somebody to change.
Sometimes, we need to stop measuring our lives against an expectation that was never realistic.
And sometimes, we need to acknowledge that the life we have is not the life we imagined.
That does not mean it has no value.
It means that we may need to find a different way of living it.
What does this mean for men in Reading?
I think this is a particularly important conversation for men because many of us have been taught to approach life through action.
If something is wrong, fix it.
If something is difficult, work harder.
If something is painful, endure it.
If something is disappointing, try again.
And if something cannot be changed, perhaps you should stop talking about it.
But emotional life does not always work that way.
Sometimes, the problem cannot be fixed.
Sometimes, the relationship cannot be repaired.
Sometimes, the person does not come back.
Sometimes, the opportunity does not arrive.
Sometimes, the body does not respond in the way we hoped.
Sometimes, the career does not develop as we imagined.
Sometimes, the child we love continues to struggle.
And sometimes, we need to learn how to live with the reality that something we wanted may never happen.
For men in Reading, Tilehurst, Southcote, Caversham, Woodley, Earley, Wokingham and the surrounding towns and villages, this may involve a range of experiences.
Perhaps you are a father who has lost contact with your children.
Perhaps you are a man who has experienced addiction.
Perhaps you are struggling with a chronic health condition.
Perhaps you are grieving somebody you love.
Perhaps you are trying to understand why a relationship ended.
Perhaps you are struggling with the reality that your parents may never become the people you needed them to be.
Perhaps you are trying to make sense of your identity.
Perhaps you are working hard towards a goal that continues to feel out of reach.
And perhaps you have begun to wonder whether you are failing because your life has not turned out the way you expected.
I want to offer a different perspective.
You can be a person who is committed to change and still acknowledge that some things may not change.
You can be a person who values discipline and still recognise that effort does not guarantee success.
You can believe in love and still recognise that love cannot prevent every tragedy.
You can believe in personal responsibility and still recognise that some circumstances are beyond your control.
And you can be a person who wants to improve their life without believing that you must overcome every difficulty in order to be worthy of living it.
That is not pessimism.
It is a more realistic understanding of what it means to be human.
The therapeutic question is not always “How do we fix this?”
One of the things I value about psychotherapy is that it gives us the opportunity to ask different questions.
Sometimes, the question is:
How do we change this?
How do we reduce the distress?
How do we develop new coping strategies?
How do we improve the relationship?
How do we work towards recovery?
These are important questions.
But sometimes, the question is different.
What does it mean to live with this?
What have you lost?
What do you need to grieve?
What can you still influence?
What matters to you, even in the presence of this difficulty?
What would it look like to stop judging yourself for something you cannot control?
What would it look like to develop a life that is meaningful, even if this particular difficulty remains?
And perhaps most importantly:
What would it look like to recognise that you are more than the thing you are struggling with?
Because a person is not their addiction.
A person is not their diagnosis.
A person is not their grief.
A person is not their failed relationship.
A person is not their financial difficulties.
A person is not their childhood.
A person is not the worst thing that has happened to them.
And a person is not defined exclusively by the things they have been unable to overcome.
This is where I think the therapeutic relationship can be particularly meaningful.
It offers a space in which a person does not have to prove that they are getting better.
They do not have to perform resilience.
They do not have to turn their suffering into a success story.
They can simply begin to understand what they are experiencing.
And perhaps, in that understanding, something begins to change.
Not necessarily the circumstances.
But their relationship with themselves.
Their relationship with their emotions.
Their relationship with the people around them.
And their understanding of what it means to live a meaningful life.
Not everything has an explanation. Not everything has an answer.
I want to return to the philosophical question that started this conversation.
Why do we find it so difficult to accept that not everything can be fixed?
Perhaps because we have been taught to believe that suffering is a problem that must eventually be solved.
Perhaps because we want to believe that if we work hard enough, we can control the outcomes of our lives.
Perhaps because we are frightened of uncertainty.
Perhaps because we want to believe that the people we love will always be safe.
Perhaps because we want to believe that the things we do will always produce the results we expect.
Perhaps because we want to believe that the world is fair.
But the world is not always fair.
People suffer.
People die.
People experience things they never deserved.
People make decisions that have consequences.
People lose opportunities.
People experience disappointment.
And sometimes, there is no explanation that makes these experiences acceptable.
This does not mean that life has no meaning.
It means that meaning may not always be found in the explanation.
Sometimes, meaning is found in the way we respond.
Sometimes, it is found in the relationships we develop.
Sometimes, it is found in the things we continue to value.
Sometimes, it is found in the people we help.
Sometimes, it is found in the lives we build alongside our difficulties.
And sometimes, it is found in the simple recognition that we are still here.
Still living.
Still experiencing.
Still capable of connection.
Still capable of love.
Still capable of making choices.
Even when some of the things we hoped for have not happened.
Even when some of the things we wanted have been lost.
Even when some of the difficulties we experience may remain part of our lives.
Perhaps we do not need to overcome everything in order to live.
Perhaps we do not need to heal everything in order to love.
Perhaps we do not need to understand everything in order to find meaning.
And perhaps we do not need to turn every painful experience into something positive.
Sometimes, something is simply painful.
Sometimes, something is simply unfair.
Sometimes, something is simply tragic.
And perhaps we need to allow ourselves to acknowledge that.
Not because we are giving up.
But because we are recognising the reality of the human experience.
A final thought: You are allowed to have a life that is not a success story
I think one of the most important things we can communicate to men is that they do not have to turn their lives into a success story.
You do not have to become extraordinarily successful because you had a difficult childhood.
You do not have to become wealthy because you grew up in poverty.
You do not have to become famous because you were overlooked.
You do not have to become exceptionally strong because you experienced weakness.
You do not have to become a perfect father because your own father was absent.
You do not have to become an extraordinary partner because you have experienced rejection.
You do not have to recover in a particular way to prove that you are worthy of love.
And you do not have to overcome every difficulty to demonstrate that your life has value.
Perhaps you will achieve the things you want.
Perhaps you will recover from the difficulties you are experiencing.
Perhaps you will find love.
Perhaps you will develop the relationships you have always wanted.
Perhaps you will achieve the career you have been working towards.
And perhaps you will experience a future that is very different from the one you imagined.
But perhaps some things will remain difficult.
Perhaps some relationships will never be repaired.
Perhaps some experiences will continue to affect you.
Perhaps some dreams will never become reality.
And perhaps you will need to learn how to live with those things.
That does not mean that your life has failed.
It means that your life is a human life.
And human lives are not always neat.
They are not always fair.
They are not always predictable.
They are not always happy.
But they can still be meaningful.
They can still contain love.
They can still contain connection.
They can still contain moments of joy.
They can still contain experiences that matter.
And they can still be worth living.
Not everything can be fixed. Not everything can be healed. Not everything can be overcome.
But perhaps the most important question is not whether we can overcome every difficulty.
Perhaps it is whether we can learn to live with ourselves, and with one another, in a world where some difficulties remain.
Because sometimes, the most courageous thing a man can do is not to keep fighting.
Sometimes, it is to stop blaming himself for something he cannot change.
Sometimes, it is to acknowledge that he is hurting.
Sometimes, it is to ask for help.
Sometimes, it is to grieve.
Sometimes, it is to accept that the life he has is different from the life he wanted.
And sometimes, it is to recognise that he is still worthy of love, connection and a meaningful future.
Not because he has overcome everything.
But because he is human.
And perhaps that is enough.
Male Minds Counselling | Reading, Berkshire
If you recognise something of yourself in this article, counselling can offer a space to explore the things you are struggling with, the things you can change, and the things you may need support in learning to live with.
At Male Minds Counselling, I work with boys and men in Reading and across Berkshire, including men experiencing anxiety, depression, addiction-related difficulties, relationship problems, grief, loss and challenges associated with masculinity.
The work is inclusive, culturally aware, masculinity-informed and trauma-informed.
You do not need to have everything figured out before you begin.
You do not need to know exactly what to say.
And you do not need to pretend that everything is fine.
Male Minds Counselling
Website: malemindscounselling.com
Email: malemindscounselling@gmail.com
Based in Reading, Berkshire. Online and in-person counselling available.
A free 30-minute Zoom assessment is available.
Further reading and research
- Boss, P. (2013). ‘The myth of closure’. Journal of Family Theory & Review, 5(1), pp. 18–23.
- Camus, A. (1942). The Myth of Sisyphus.
- Hayes, S.C., Strosahl, K.D. and Wilson, K.G. (2012). Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: The Process and Practice of Mindful Change. 2nd edn. New York: Guilford Press.
- Nietzsche, F. (1886). Beyond Good and Evil.
- Schopenhauer, A. (1818/1844). The World as Will and Representation.
- Ye, X. et al. (2024). ‘Acceptance and commitment therapy for patients with chronic pain: A systematic review and meta-analysis on psychological outcomes and quality of life’. PLOS ONE, 19(6), e0301226. Read the research.
- National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism. ‘Alcohol Use Disorder: From Risk to Diagnosis to Recovery’. Read the clinical guidance.
- Chopra, A. et al. (2022). ‘Risk factors for intimate partner homicide in England and Wales’. Health & Social Care in the Community. Read the research.
- Home Office (2023). Controlling or coercive behaviour: Statutory guidance framework. Read the statutory guidance.
