There is a particular conversation that I have heard many times in my counselling practice. It usually begins with a man describing a problem he is experiencing in his relationship. He might say something along these lines:
“My partner tells me something is bothering her, and my immediate response is to tell her what I would do. Usually, I would just get on with it, shut up and deal with it. But apparently, that isn’t what she wants to hear. Sometimes she just cries, and I honestly don’t know what to do. I feel stuck. My partner has told me that she doesn’t feel comfortable being vulnerable with me because it’s like talking to a brick wall.
“I don’t understand it. If something is bothering me, I try to fix it. So when she comes to me in turmoil, I find myself thinking, why are you coming to me if you don’t want advice? Sometimes I text her something like ‘that sucks’, but apparently that comes across as disingenuous. I don’t know what else I’m supposed to say. I feel like I’m disappointing her little by little every time we have one of these conversations.”
I think there is something important in this conversation that deserves our attention.
Firstly, these men are not unique. There are many men who experience difficulties recognising, understanding and responding to other people’s emotions. Some have never really been taught how to do it. Others have learnt to manage their own emotions by suppressing them, rationalising them or finding practical solutions to whatever is causing them distress.
And sometimes, these strategies have served them remarkably well.
They might be successful in their careers, financially independent, disciplined, ambitious and capable of managing considerable responsibility. They might be excellent problem solvers. They might even consider themselves emotionally intelligent because they are comfortable discussing what they think and feel.
However, being successful in one area of life does not necessarily mean that we have mastered the other areas.
There is a difference between professional competence, intellectual intelligence, spirituality, emotional literacy, interpersonal skills, adaptability and wisdom. These are different dimensions of human development.
You can be highly intelligent but struggle to understand another person’s emotional experience. You can be spiritually developed but lack the interpersonal skills required to maintain a healthy relationship. You can be financially successful but struggle to make someone feel emotionally safe.
And you can be an open book about your own experiences whilst remaining relatively disconnected from the emotional experiences of the people around you.
This is where I want to introduce the subject of empathy.
Because empathy is not simply about being a nice person, feeling sorry for somebody or knowing what to say when someone cries. It is a psychological and relational skill that can be developed.
And, importantly, it takes time and practice.
Empathy is not the same as fixing someone’s problems
One of the first things I would encourage men to understand is that empathy and problem-solving are two different psychological processes.
When somebody comes to you with a problem, your brain might immediately start looking for a solution.
You hear that your partner has had a difficult day at work. You identify the problem, consider the available options and offer a practical response.
From your perspective, you are helping.
You might even think that you are demonstrating love. You are trying to make their life easier. You are offering something useful. You are doing what you would want somebody to do for you.
But there is a problem.
You are responding to the problem rather than the person experiencing the problem.
Let me give you an example.
Imagine your partner comes home and says: “I’ve had an absolutely awful day. My manager embarrassed me in front of everyone, and I’ve been thinking about it all afternoon.”
Here are two possible responses.
Response A: The problem solver
“Why don’t you just speak to your manager? If you’re unhappy there, find another job. You shouldn’t let people treat you like that.”
Response B: The empathic response
“That sounds really uncomfortable. Especially having it happen in front of everybody. I imagine you’ve been replaying it in your head all afternoon. What happened?”
Notice the difference.
The first response moves immediately towards a solution. The second response attempts to understand the emotional experience.
Neither response necessarily comes from bad intentions. However, they communicate very different things.
The first can leave somebody feeling that their emotions are inconvenient, irrational or something they need to get over.
The second communicates that their experience matters enough for you to stop, listen and understand.
This is something explored in relationship psychology through the concept of perceived partner responsiveness.
Researchers Beyzanur Arican-Dinc and Shelly Gable (2023) explain that intimacy is partly shaped by whether somebody feels understood, validated and cared for when they disclose something personal to their partner.
In other words, relationships are not maintained exclusively through practical support. They are also maintained through the experience of feeling emotionally recognised by another person.
And this is where some men need to reconsider what they understand by helping.
Sometimes helping somebody means doing something.
Sometimes helping somebody means sitting with them whilst they experience something.
Not every emotional problem is an invitation for you to become a mechanic. Sometimes somebody just wants you to sit in the passenger seat with them.
Understand the difference between sympathy, empathy and emotional validation
I think it is useful to distinguish three concepts because they are often confused.
Sympathy is recognising that somebody is experiencing difficulty and feeling concern for them.
For example: “That’s terrible. I’m sorry that happened.”
Empathy involves making an effort to understand the experience from the other person’s perspective.
For example: “I can understand why that would have upset you, especially considering how much effort you’ve put into this.”
Emotional validation involves communicating that somebody’s emotional experience is understandable and deserves to be acknowledged.
For example: “It makes sense that you’re feeling disappointed. You were expecting something different, and it clearly meant a lot to you.”
There is something particularly important about validation.
Validation does not mean agreeing with everything somebody says. It does not mean accepting every interpretation as fact. It does not mean abandoning your own opinions or pretending that somebody is always right.
You can disagree with someone’s interpretation whilst recognising their emotional experience.
For example: “I see things slightly differently, but I can understand why you felt hurt by what happened.”
That is very different from: “You’re being ridiculous. It shouldn’t bother you.”
The latter dismisses the experience. The former makes room for two people to have different perspectives without one person having to invalidate the other.
This distinction is particularly important in romantic relationships because emotional safety does not require two people to think identically. It requires them to feel that they can express themselves without automatically being criticised, corrected or dismissed.
Learn to become curious about somebody else’s emotional world
One of the biggest changes a man can make is to become more curious.
I sometimes think that we spend so much of our lives preparing our responses that we forget to become interested in the person speaking to us.
We are listening, but we are not necessarily listening to understand.
We are listening to establish what happened, identify who was responsible, decide whether the person is right or wrong and work out what we would do differently.
But empathy requires something different.
It requires you to temporarily put your own perspective to one side.
Consider the following questions:
- What might this person be feeling?
- What has this experience meant to them?
- What are they worried about?
- What might they need from me right now?
- What is it like to experience this situation from their position?
- Is there something underneath what they are telling me?
- What have they not quite managed to put into words?
For example, your partner might tell you that she is upset because you forgot something important.
You might immediately think, “It was only a small thing. I’ve got a lot going on. Why is this becoming such a big issue?”
But what if the issue is not actually the forgotten event?
Perhaps it represents something much bigger.
Perhaps she feels that she is always the one remembering birthdays, arranging things, organising the household and keeping track of the relationship.
Perhaps the forgotten event has activated a feeling that she is not considered.
Perhaps what she is really trying to communicate is: “I want to feel that you think about me without me having to remind you.”
Now you are having a completely different conversation.
You have moved beyond the event and started exploring its emotional meaning.
This is what curiosity allows us to do.
Instead of assuming that we already understand somebody, we ask questions that help us discover what their experience actually means to them.
Some useful questions include:
- “What was the hardest part about that?”
- “How did that make you feel?”
- “What do you think upset you most?”
- “Have you been carrying this around for a while?”
- “What do you wish had happened instead?”
- “Is there something about this that I might not be understanding?”
And sometimes, the most useful question is simply: “Can you tell me a little more?”
You do not need to become a psychologist in your relationship. You just need to become interested in the person you are sharing your life with.
Learn to tolerate emotions without immediately trying to remove them
This is an important one. Some men struggle with their partner’s emotions because they have very little experience sitting comfortably with emotional discomfort.
When somebody cries, becomes upset, expresses disappointment or starts talking about something painful, they experience an internal pressure to make it stop.
They might become uncomfortable, irritated, defensive or anxious.
They might think:
- I don’t know what to say.
- Why are they crying?
- What am I supposed to do?
- How long is this going to last?
- Why can’t we just sort this out?
- Am I doing something wrong?
- Why isn’t my advice helping?
And because they do not know what to do with the discomfort, they try to eliminate it.
They offer solutions. They change the subject. They minimise the situation. They become defensive. Sometimes they withdraw completely.
But here is something worth considering.
Your partner’s emotional discomfort is not necessarily an emergency that requires you to intervene.
Sometimes people need to experience their emotions without having somebody immediately trying to change them.
Think about grief. Think about disappointment. Think about embarrassment, rejection, loneliness or feeling overwhelmed.
These are normal human experiences. You cannot necessarily solve them, and you certainly cannot prevent the people you love from experiencing them.
What you can do is become somebody who is capable of remaining emotionally present whilst they experience them.
There is a difference between being unable to tolerate somebody else’s sadness and being willing to sit alongside it.
For men who have learnt that emotional control means suppressing difficult feelings, this can require considerable practice.
It means learning that another person’s tears do not automatically mean you have failed.
You do not have to make the tears disappear to demonstrate that you care.
Sometimes you can simply say:
“I’m here. Take your time.”
Or: “I don’t know exactly what to say, but I want you to know that I’m listening.”
That is not weakness. It is emotional availability.
Understand where you learnt to respond to emotions in this way
I think this is where the conversation becomes particularly interesting from a psychological perspective. Because we need to ask ourselves an important question.
Where did you learn what to do with emotions?
Think about your childhood.
When you were upset, what happened?
Did somebody sit with you and ask what was wrong?
Did somebody acknowledge your feelings?
Were you allowed to cry?
Could you express disappointment, fear or sadness without being told to stop?
Or were you told things like:
- Stop crying.
- Man up.
- Get over it.
- Don’t be so sensitive.
- Nobody cares.
- Life isn’t fair.
- Just get on with it.
- There’s no point feeling sorry for yourself.
For some boys, emotional expression was actively discouraged. For others, there simply wasn’t anybody emotionally available enough to demonstrate what healthy emotional communication looked like.
Perhaps the adults around them were working hard, dealing with financial difficulties, managing their own emotional struggles or simply repeating the parenting they had experienced.
The boy grows up learning that emotions are something to manage privately.
He might become incredibly independent, self-reliant and capable of functioning under pressure.
But he may not develop the same capacity to recognise, articulate and respond to emotions in other people.
This is not an argument that all men have the same childhood experiences, or that every difficulty with empathy comes from masculinity or upbringing.
There are many possible influences, including temperament, family relationships, attachment experiences, neurodivergence, stress, emotional avoidance and learned communication patterns.
However, traditional masculine expectations can sometimes reinforce the belief that emotional vulnerability is something to overcome rather than something to understand.
And this can create difficulties later in adult relationships.
A man might genuinely believe he is being helpful when he tells his partner to stop worrying because that is precisely how he has learnt to treat his own worries.
He might be applying the same emotional rules to somebody else that he has applied to himself for twenty or thirty years.
But here is the question I would encourage him to consider:
Just because you learnt to survive by shutting down your emotions, does that mean the people you love should have to experience relationships with you in the same way?
There is an opportunity here to develop something different.
You can retain your resilience, independence and ability to solve problems whilst developing the capacity to be emotionally receptive.
You do not have to choose between being strong and being empathetic.
Practise the four stages of an empathic conversation
If you are somebody who genuinely does not know what to say when your partner is upset, I would encourage you to start with four simple stages.
Stage 1
Listen
Stop preparing your response. Give the other person your attention. Put your phone down, maintain appropriate eye contact and allow them to finish speaking.
Your job is not to win an argument or identify a solution. Your job is to understand.
Stage 2
Reflect
Try to communicate what you have understood.
“So, what you’re saying is that you felt ignored when I did that?”
“It sounds like you’ve been feeling quite alone with this.”
You are checking whether you have understood rather than assuming you have.
Stage 3
Validate
Acknowledge the emotional experience.
“I can understand why that upset you.”
“That sounds like it was really difficult.”
“I hadn’t realised how much this was affecting you.”
You are communicating that their feelings are worth taking seriously.
Stage 4
Explore what they need
Rather than assuming they want advice, ask:
“Would you like me to listen, help you think through it, or would you prefer a bit of reassurance?”
This gives the other person an opportunity to communicate what would actually help.
These stages are not a rigid formula. You do not need to work through them mechanically every time somebody speaks.
They are a way of slowing down your automatic response and developing a different habit.
The research on high-quality listening by Itzchakov, Reis and Weinstein (2022) is particularly relevant here. Their work explores how listening can help people feel understood, positively regarded and cared for, which in turn supports perceived responsiveness in relationships.
Learn to change the language you use
Sometimes men tell me that they understand the theory but still struggle with the actual words.
They say: “What am I supposed to say? I can’t just keep saying that sucks.”
And I think that is a fair question.
So let’s look at some examples.
Instead of saying...
Try saying...
“That sucks.”
“I’m sorry. That sounds like a really difficult day.”
“Just ignore them.”
“I can see why what they said has stayed with you.”
“It shouldn’t bother you.”
“I didn’t realise it was affecting you this much.”
“You’re overthinking it.”
“What’s been going through your mind?”
“Just fix it.”
“What do you think you need right now?”
“What’s the point of worrying?”
“I can understand why you’re worried about what might happen.”
“It’s not that serious.”
“It might not seem obvious to me, but I can see that it matters to you.”
“I would just...”
“What do you think would help?”
“Calm down.”
“Let’s take a moment. I’m listening.”
“I’ve already told you what to do.”
“Perhaps I moved too quickly into trying to solve this.”
Notice that none of these responses require you to become particularly poetic, emotionally sophisticated or articulate.
They require you to become more attentive.
And one of the most important things you can do is stop assuming that your experience of a situation is the same as your partner’s.
You might not have been bothered by what happened.
You might have dealt with it differently.
You might have made a completely different decision.
But empathy asks you to understand their experience rather than use your own experience as the measurement for whether their feelings are justified.
What about when you’re communicating through text messages?
This is another important part of the original conversation. Some couples communicate throughout the day using WhatsApp or text messages. One person might disclose something emotionally significant, and the other responds with a short message.
“That sucks.”
“Sorry to hear that.”
“Hope you’re okay.”
“Just try not to worry.”
Sometimes these messages are perfectly well-intentioned. But they can also leave the person on the receiving end feeling that their emotional disclosure has been brushed aside.
Text communication has limitations. You cannot always communicate warmth, tone, facial expression or emotional presence through a few words on a screen.
And sometimes, the person receiving the message needs more than an acknowledgement.
For example: Your partner: “I’m honestly so upset about what happened today. I feel like nobody appreciates me.”
A short response: “That sucks.”
A more emotionally engaged response: “I’m sorry you’re feeling like that. I know how much you’ve been putting into everything lately. Do you want to tell me what happened? I’m happy to call if you’d rather talk.”
There is a significant difference.
The second response demonstrates that you have considered what they have communicated.
It also offers an opportunity for connection.
And if you are not particularly good at communicating through text, there is nothing wrong with saying: “I want to give this the attention it deserves rather than send you a half-hearted response. Can I call you when I have a proper moment?”
That is much better than sending something dismissive because you feel pressured to respond immediately.
However, be careful not to make every emotional conversation about your discomfort with texting. Sometimes a simple, thoughtful response is enough.
Recognise the cycle that might be developing in your relationship
There is another psychological pattern worth exploring. Sometimes couples unintentionally develop a cycle in which one person pursues emotional connection and the other withdraws from it.
For example:
- Your partner experiences something upsetting and comes to you looking for emotional support.
- You feel uncomfortable or uncertain about what to say.
- You offer advice, minimise the problem or suggest a solution.
- Your partner feels misunderstood, dismissed or emotionally alone.
- They become more upset and try harder to explain why they need you to understand.
- You feel criticised, frustrated or inadequate.
- You withdraw, become defensive or stop communicating.
- Your partner becomes increasingly reluctant to be vulnerable with you.
Eventually, both people can feel rejected.
One feels that nothing they do is good enough. The other feels that their emotional needs are not being met.
What is important here is that the problem is not necessarily that one person cares and the other doesn’t.
It may be that they have developed very different ways of communicating, seeking reassurance and responding to emotional discomfort.
Attachment-informed approaches to couples work explore precisely these patterns of communicating needs and responding to one another. Seedall and Wampler (2024), for example, examine the importance of partners being able to communicate their needs clearly and respond appropriately to each other.
The important thing is to recognise the cycle before it becomes the defining feature of your relationship.
Instead of asking, “Why does she keep getting upset with me?” you might start asking:
“What happens between us when she becomes upset, and what role do I play in that interaction?”
That is a much more productive question.
Practise empathy outside your romantic relationship
I would also encourage men not to treat empathy as something they only need when their partner is upset. Empathy is a capacity that can be developed throughout everyday life.
You can practise it with your friends, colleagues, children, parents, siblings and even people you disagree with.
Try some of the following exercises.
Exercise 1: The three-minute listening exercise
The next time somebody tells you about something happening in their life, give them three minutes without interrupting, correcting or offering advice.
Your objective is to understand their experience.
At the end, summarise what you have heard.
Ask them whether you have understood correctly.
Exercise 2: The perspective-taking exercise
When somebody does something that frustrates you, pause and consider three possible explanations for their behaviour.
For example, somebody doesn’t respond to your message.
Your immediate interpretation might be that they are ignoring you.
But perhaps they are overwhelmed, distracted or dealing with something you know nothing about.
You do not have to assume the most positive explanation. You are simply learning not to treat your first interpretation as the only possible explanation.
Exercise 3: The emotional vocabulary exercise
Many people struggle with empathy because they have a limited emotional vocabulary.
They recognise that somebody is upset but cannot identify what that upset might consist of.
Start learning to distinguish between emotions.
For example:
- Disappointment.
- Embarrassment.
- Shame.
- Rejection.
- Loneliness.
- Insecurity.
- Jealousy.
- Resentment.
- Grief.
- Fear.
- Helplessness.
- Frustration.
- Overwhelm.
- Guilt.
- Humiliation.
The more accurately you can recognise emotions, the better equipped you become to understand what somebody might be experiencing.
Exercise 4: Ask yourself one question every evening
At the end of each day, reflect on one interaction you have had.
Ask yourself:
“Was I interested in understanding that person’s experience, or was I more interested in telling them what I thought?”
There is no need to criticise yourself.
Simply become aware of your patterns.
Awareness gives you something to work with.
How can counselling help you develop empathy?
This is where I think counselling can be particularly valuable. One of the misconceptions about counselling is that people only attend when they have a mental health condition, are experiencing a crisis or have something particularly traumatic to discuss.
But counselling can also be a space for personal development.
You might come to counselling because you want to understand why you struggle with emotional intimacy.
Perhaps you recognise that you are good at providing financially but struggle to provide emotional support.
Perhaps you are comfortable talking about yourself but struggle to show interest in somebody else’s internal world.
Perhaps you become defensive whenever somebody expresses disappointment in you.
Perhaps you struggle when somebody cries because you have never learnt what to do with your own sadness.
These are all things that can be explored.
In a therapeutic relationship, you can begin to examine your emotional development, attachment experiences, family dynamics, beliefs about masculinity and the ways you have learnt to relate to other people.
You might discover that you have developed a particularly strong relationship with logic, rationality and problem-solving because these are the areas where you feel most competent.
You might discover that emotional conversations activate feelings of inadequacy, helplessness or shame.
You might recognise that when somebody expresses an emotional need, you interpret it as criticism.
Or perhaps you simply haven’t had enough opportunities to develop the skills associated with emotional communication.
Different therapeutic approaches can help in different ways.
- Person-centred counselling: Provides an opportunity to experience empathy, acceptance and genuine understanding, whilst exploring how these qualities can be developed in your own relationships.
- Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT): Can help identify automatic thoughts such as “They’re overreacting”, “I need to fix this” or “I’m being criticised”, and examine how these thoughts influence your responses.
- Psychodynamic counselling: Can help explore how earlier relationships and childhood experiences might influence your current emotional patterns.
- Transactional analysis: Can help you recognise recurring communication patterns, defensive responses and the different relational positions you adopt when interacting with others.
- Emotionally focused couples therapy: Can help couples understand the emotional cycles that develop between them and practise responding to vulnerability with greater acceptance and compassion.
Research into emotion-focused couples therapy has explored the importance of helping partners express vulnerable feelings and needs, and enabling the other partner to respond with acceptance and compassion. Kula and colleagues (2022) found associations between therapeutic interventions that promoted acceptance of feelings and needs and couples’ reports of greater emotional injury resolution.
The objective isn’t to turn you into somebody who constantly agrees with everyone or feels responsible for everybody else’s emotions.
It is to help you develop a greater capacity to understand yourself and other people.
And perhaps most importantly, to learn how to remain connected to somebody even when their emotional experience is different from your own.
A final thought: You can be a strong man and still learn to be emotionally available
I want to finish with something that I think is particularly important for men.
There is a difference between being able to manage your own life and being able to participate emotionally in somebody else’s.
You might have learnt to get through difficult circumstances by putting your head down, getting on with things and refusing to let emotions interfere with your responsibilities.
There is certainly a place for resilience, determination and personal responsibility.
But relationships require something else from us.
They require adaptability.
They require us to recognise that the person sitting opposite us might experience the world differently. They might need reassurance where we need independence. They might need conversation where we need silence. They might need affection where we need space.
And sometimes, loving somebody means learning how to respond to needs that we don’t personally have.
I think this is one of the more important aspects of adult development.
You are not simply learning how to become a better version of yourself in isolation. You are learning how to become somebody who can participate in the growth and development of another human being.
You can be ambitious and compassionate.
You can be disciplined and emotionally available.
You can be rational and understanding.
You can be independent and still allow somebody to lean on you.
And you can disagree with somebody without making them feel that their emotions are a problem.
Perhaps the question isn’t simply how you gain empathy.
Perhaps the deeper question is whether you are prepared to become curious about experiences that you have never personally understood.
Because the person you love does not need you to experience everything they experience.
They need to know that you are willing to try to understand.
And that is something you can practise, develop and get better at.
Empathy is not about having the perfect response. It is about helping another person feel that they do not have to experience everything alone.
Further reading and research
For anyone interested in exploring the psychological research behind this article, I would recommend the following:
1. Arican-Dinc, B. and Gable, S.L. (2023). Responsiveness in romantic partners’ interactions. Current Opinion in Psychology, 53, 101652. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2023.101652
2. Itzchakov, G., Reis, H.T. and Weinstein, N. (2022). How to foster perceived partner responsiveness: High-quality listening is key. Social and Personality Psychology Compass. https://doi.org/10.1111/spc3.12648
3. Cohen, S., Schulz, M.S., Weiss, E. and Waldinger, R.J. (2012). Eye of the beholder: The individual and dyadic contributions of empathic accuracy and perceived empathic effort to relationship satisfaction. Journal of Family Psychology, 26(2), 236–245. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0027488
4. Seedall, R.B. and Wampler, K.S. (2024). An attachment perspective on couple interaction: Helping couples signal needs clearly and respond appropriately. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 50(2), 267–289. https://doi.org/10.1111/jmft.12684
5. Crasta, D., Rogge, R.D., Maniaci, M.R. and Reis, H.T. (2021). Toward an optimized measure of perceived partner responsiveness: Development and validation of the perceived responsiveness and insensitivity scale. Psychological Assessment, 33(4), 338–355. https://doi.org/10.1037/pas0000986
Counselling for men in Reading and Berkshire
At Male Minds Counselling, I work with boys and men who want to understand themselves, their relationships, their emotional experiences and the patterns that sometimes prevent them from developing the relationships they want.
You do not have to wait until your relationship is falling apart to start exploring these things.
Sometimes the most valuable work begins when you recognise that there are areas of your life where you would like to develop.
Male Minds Counselling
Reading, Berkshire | Online and in-person counselling
Website: malemindscounselling.com
Email: malemindscounselling@gmail.com
You can arrange a free 30-minute introductory Zoom conversation to discuss whether counselling might be helpful.
