There is a question that I have wanted to explore for some time, and it is one that I think deserves considerably more attention than we give it. Do people truly change?
I have been following the trial of Russell Brand over the past few weeks, and something that happened in court recently really made me think about this question. On 29 October 2026, Brand’s wife, Laura Brand, gave evidence as a character witness in his defence. She described him as caring, kind, a wonderful father and an attentive husband. She also spoke about the history of their relationship and the difficulties they had experienced when they first dated.
Brand is currently facing allegations of sexual offences involving six women. He has pleaded not guilty to the charges, and the proceedings are ongoing. The allegations are not findings of guilt, and it is important that we distinguish between what is alleged, what is established and what remains for the court to determine.
But I am not particularly interested in using this article to decide whether Russell Brand is guilty or innocent. That is a matter for the court.
What interests me is the psychological question that sits underneath the public conversation.
How do we understand a person who appears to have changed their life, who may now be a loving husband, a present father, a committed Christian or somebody who has developed a different relationship with themselves, when there are allegations or established accounts of behaviour from their past that have caused significant harm to other people?
Can somebody genuinely become a different person? And perhaps the more difficult question is this. What happens when you have changed, but the people you hurt have not been able to move on from what you did?
What if your behaviour altered somebody else’s life? What if they experienced trauma, lost their sense of safety, developed difficulties in relationships or spent years trying to understand something that you have since moved on from?
Should you be forgiven? Should your past be wiped away because you are now a different person?
And, perhaps even more importantly, are you genuinely different, or have you simply adapted to a new environment in which your old behaviour is no longer necessary, convenient or acceptable?
These are questions that I believe are particularly important when we work with boys and men. Because in counselling, we often talk about change as though it is a relatively straightforward process. We identify a problem, explore its origins, develop insight, change the behaviour and move forward.
But human beings are considerably more complicated than that. A man can stop drinking without understanding why he drank. He can stop being physically aggressive without developing the emotional capacity to tolerate frustration. He can enter a relationship without changing the beliefs he holds about women. He can become successful without becoming emotionally available. He can become religious without developing greater compassion.
Equally, a man can spend years believing that he is incapable of change, only to discover that with the right support, relationships, therapeutic intervention and willingness to understand himself, he is capable of becoming somebody he never thought he could be.
So, before we begin discussing whether people change, I think we need to establish what we actually mean by change.
What do we mean when we talk about change?
When I ask whether people change, I am not necessarily asking whether they behave differently. I am asking whether something has changed within the person themselves.
There is a difference between changing your circumstances, changing your behaviour, changing your beliefs, changing your personality and changing the way you understand other human beings.
These are not necessarily the same thing.
A man who previously drank every evening and now attends Alcoholics Anonymous has changed his behaviour. A man who previously responded to conflict by shouting and now walks away has changed his behavioural response. A man who previously believed that women should accommodate his emotional needs and now understands relationships as reciprocal has potentially changed something much deeper.
But how do we know? This is where psychological research becomes particularly interesting, because it challenges the idea that personality is either completely fixed or infinitely changeable. Neither position is entirely accurate.
Biological change: the human body is not a finished product
We know that human beings change biologically throughout their lives. Children grow. Adolescents experience puberty. Adults age. Our bodies respond to changes in nutrition, physical activity, hormones, illness and our surrounding environment.
We also know that development can be interrupted. For example, children who experience prolonged nutritional deprivation may experience impaired growth and development. When the circumstances change and adequate nutrition becomes available, some children experience catch-up growth.
This is important because it demonstrates that development is not simply a matter of what we are born with. Our environment can influence what happens to us.
But I think we need to be careful when we extend this analogy to psychological development. A person who has experienced childhood neglect does not necessarily develop the same psychological difficulties as another child who experienced similar circumstances. Nor does the provision of a supportive environment automatically reverse every developmental consequence.
Human development involves an interaction between biology, relationships, experiences and the environment.
And this is where I think the conversation about men becomes particularly interesting.
If a boy grows up in an environment where vulnerability is ridiculed, emotional expression is punished and anger is the only acceptable way of communicating distress, he may develop a particular way of relating to the world.
He may learn to suppress sadness. He may become uncomfortable with intimacy. He may interpret rejection as humiliation. He may experience emotional dependence as weakness.
And he may develop a nervous system that responds to perceived threats with aggression, withdrawal or emotional shutdown.
But does that mean he is destined to remain that way?
No.
It means that we need to understand the developmental processes that contributed to the behaviour, while recognising that understanding those processes does not remove responsibility for what the person does with them.
This distinction is important. Understanding why somebody behaves in a particular way is not the same as excusing the behaviour. And it is a distinction that I think we need to teach boys and men much earlier in life.
Personality: are some people simply incapable of changing?
One of the things I find fascinating about personality psychology is that it challenges the belief that we are permanently fixed in the person we become during childhood.
For a long time, people have talked about personality as though it is something that becomes established early in life and remains relatively unchanged. You hear people say things like, “That’s just the way he is”, “He’s always been like that” or “You can’t teach an old dog new tricks.”
But research suggests that this is an oversimplification.
Roberts, Walton and Viechtbauer (2006) conducted a meta-analysis of 92 longitudinal studies examining personality development across the lifespan. Their findings indicated that personality traits such as conscientiousness, social dominance and emotional stability tend to increase, particularly during young adulthood.
In other words, people can become more emotionally stable, more conscientious and more socially mature as they move through life.
This is particularly interesting when we consider the development of boys and young men.
A 19-year-old man living in Woodley or Caversham who struggles with impulsivity, emotional regulation or maintaining relationships may not necessarily be displaying a permanent personality characteristic. He may be at a particular stage of psychological development, responding to particular environmental pressures or struggling with experiences that he has not yet learned how to process.
And this matters because of the way we sometimes talk about men.
We label them emotionally unavailable, narcissistic, avoidant, aggressive or immature, and then begin to treat those descriptions as though they are permanent identities.
But a psychological description should help us understand a person. It should not automatically become a life sentence.
That said, I do not want to suggest that every aspect of personality is easily changed.
Some psychological difficulties are persistent, complex and require long-term therapeutic intervention. For example, narcissistic personality disorder can involve difficulties with empathy, self-esteem regulation, interpersonal functioning and the capacity to tolerate criticism. These difficulties may affect a person’s relationships over many years.
But even here, I think we need to be careful. It is not clinically accurate to say that people with narcissistic personality disorder are incapable of change. Nor is it appropriate to assume that somebody who behaves selfishly, manipulates others or struggles with empathy necessarily has a personality disorder.
Personality disorders are complex clinical presentations, and treatment outcomes vary.
The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) recommends psychological interventions for antisocial personality disorder, including cognitive and behavioural approaches. For people with particularly complex presentations, treatment may need to be adapted, extended and accompanied by ongoing support.
The point is not that change is guaranteed.
The point is that difficulty changing should not be confused with an absolute inability to change.
And perhaps we need to move away from asking whether a person can change their personality entirely, and begin asking which aspects of their functioning can change, under what conditions, through which interventions and over what period of time.
That is a much more useful question.
The difference between changing your behaviour and changing yourself
I think this is one of the most important distinctions in the entire conversation.
Imagine a man who has spent ten years in a relationship in which he regularly shouts at his partner, controls who she sees, checks her phone and becomes angry whenever she disagrees with him.
Eventually, the relationship ends. He begins counselling.
He learns about emotional regulation, attachment, cognitive distortions and the impact of controlling behaviour. He begins to recognise that his fear of abandonment has contributed to his need for control.
He develops greater self-awareness. He learns to tolerate difficult emotions.
He begins to understand that his partner is a separate person with her own needs, boundaries and right to autonomy.
A year later, he enters another relationship.
This time, he behaves differently.
He does not check his partner’s phone. He does not tell her who she can see. He is able to tolerate disagreement without becoming aggressive.
Has he changed?
I would argue that there is evidence of change.
But now consider a slightly different example.
A man has behaved in a controlling way throughout several relationships. He has experienced consequences. He has lost partners, friends and perhaps even access to his children.
He begins to understand that his behaviour is no longer working for him.
He stops shouting.
He stops checking phones.
He becomes more careful about how he communicates.
But internally, he still believes that a partner should prioritise him above everybody else. He still experiences disagreement as disrespect. He still believes that a woman who loves him should accommodate his emotional needs.
He has learned to manage his behaviour, but he has not necessarily changed the beliefs that underpin it.
Now, I am not suggesting that behavioural change is unimportant. In fact, it can be the first and most necessary stage of recovery.
But there is a difference between behavioural compliance and psychological transformation.
In counselling, we might explore this through several different therapeutic approaches.
From a cognitive behavioural perspective, we might examine the beliefs, assumptions and cognitive distortions that influence the person’s behaviour.
From a psychodynamic perspective, we might explore the unconscious relational patterns, defensive processes and early experiences that contribute to the way the person relates to others.
From a person-centred perspective, we might explore the discrepancy between the person’s self-concept and their actual experiences, helping them develop greater congruence.
From a transactional analysis perspective, we might examine the relational scripts and ego states that influence how the person responds to conflict, intimacy and perceived rejection.
And from a systemic perspective, we might explore how the person’s behaviour is reinforced within their relationships, family system and wider social environment.
These approaches are not interchangeable, and they do not all explain change in the same way.
But they each offer something useful when we are trying to understand why a person behaves as they do, and what might help them develop healthier ways of relating to others.
The question becomes: Has the person simply learned how to avoid the consequences of their behaviour, or have they developed a different understanding of themselves and other people?
And perhaps we need to acknowledge that sometimes the answer is both.
A man may initially change because he wants to save his relationship. Over time, however, he may develop a deeper understanding of the impact of his behaviour.
The motivation for change does not necessarily determine the eventual depth of change.
What matters is whether the change becomes sustained, integrated and visible in the person’s relationships over time.
Why do some men change when they meet somebody?
This is something I have found particularly interesting in my own clinical work.
I have worked with men who have described significant changes in their lives following the development of an important relationship. Sometimes it is a spouse. Sometimes it is a close friend. Sometimes it is a mentor, a coach or somebody who has offered them a different way of seeing themselves.
I have heard men describe how they stopped drinking, changed their relationship with drugs, moved away from criminal behaviour or began taking their emotional wellbeing seriously after meeting somebody who mattered to them.
And I think there is something psychologically significant about this.
For some men, the experience of being loved by somebody can create a motivation to become a different person.
A man who previously believed that he had nothing to lose may begin to experience the possibility of losing something meaningful.
A man who has never experienced a secure relationship may begin to understand what it feels like to be emotionally connected to another person.
A man who has spent years believing that he is fundamentally unlovable may begin to develop a different sense of himself through the experience of being accepted.
But I think we need to be careful not to romanticise this.
A woman should not have to become a man’s rehabilitation programme.
A partner should not have to tolerate abuse, emotional instability, addiction or controlling behaviour in the hope that her love will eventually transform him.
And we should not assume that a man who has become a better partner for one woman has necessarily become a better person in every area of his life.
Nevertheless, there is research that helps us understand why relationships can facilitate change.
Laub and Sampson (1993), in their influential work on turning points in the life course, examined how adult social bonds can contribute to changes in criminal behaviour. Their research suggested that relationships, employment and other forms of social connection can play an important role in the process of desistance from crime.
In other words, people do not necessarily change in isolation.
Sometimes change occurs because somebody enters their life who creates a different set of possibilities.
But I think there is an important distinction between a relationship that motivates change and a relationship that actually supports psychological development.
Consider a man who begins behaving differently because he wants to keep his girlfriend.
That is understandable.
But if the relationship ends, what happens?
Does he return to the behaviour he previously displayed?
Or has he developed enough internal capacity to continue behaving differently, even when the person who initially motivated him is no longer present?
This is where I think we need to distinguish between externally motivated change and more internalised change.
The first may depend heavily on the presence of another person.
The second involves the development of values, beliefs and behavioural patterns that the individual continues to uphold even when there is no immediate reward.
And perhaps this is one of the ways we begin to understand whether change has become part of a person’s identity.
Can you develop empathy?
Another question I find particularly interesting is whether people can develop empathy.
In counselling, we often talk about empathy as though it is a single ability.
But empathy is more complex than that.
There is a distinction between cognitive empathy and affective empathy.
Cognitive empathy involves the ability to understand another person’s perspective, thoughts or emotional experience.
Affective empathy involves the capacity to experience an emotional response to another person’s feelings.
For example, a man may understand that his partner is frightened when he raises his voice.
He may recognise that his behaviour has caused distress.
But understanding that somebody is frightened is not necessarily the same as emotionally connecting with their fear.
Equally, a person may feel distressed when somebody else is upset, but struggle to understand why their own behaviour has contributed to that distress.
This distinction becomes particularly important when we are exploring harmful behaviour.
A person may possess the ability to understand other people’s emotions while still choosing to behave in ways that disregard them.
And this is why I think we need to be careful about equating empathy with moral behaviour.
Empathy can be an important part of developing healthier relationships, but it does not automatically prevent somebody from causing harm.
Consider a man who understands that his partner experiences anxiety when he threatens to leave the relationship during arguments.
He knows exactly what this does to her.
He understands the emotional impact.
But he continues to use the threat because it gives him a sense of control.
The problem is not necessarily that he lacks the ability to understand her feelings.
The problem may be that he prioritises his own emotional needs above her autonomy and wellbeing.
In this situation, developing empathy is important, but it is not sufficient.
The work may also involve accountability, emotional regulation, examining entitlement, understanding power and control, and developing the ability to tolerate frustration without resorting to coercive behaviour.
This is particularly relevant when working with men who have experienced controlling or abusive relationship patterns.
The therapeutic task is not simply to help a man become more emotionally aware.
It is to help him develop a different relationship with his own emotions, his beliefs about other people and his responsibility for the behaviour he chooses.
And I think that is a much more meaningful understanding of change.
Attachment: can a man become more secure?
I have always found attachment theory particularly interesting when thinking about psychological change.
Our early relationships can influence how we understand intimacy, trust, emotional availability and the experience of being loved.
A boy who grows up with inconsistent caregiving may learn that relationships are unpredictable.
A boy who experiences emotional neglect may learn that his needs are not important.
A boy who experiences rejection when he expresses vulnerability may learn to suppress his emotions and become self-reliant.
And these experiences can influence how he approaches relationships in adulthood.
But I think there is a misconception about attachment theory that needs to be addressed.
People sometimes speak about attachment styles as though they are permanent personality types.
You hear things like, “I’m avoidant, so I can’t do relationships”, or “I’m fearful avoidant, so I will always sabotage intimacy.”
But attachment is not a diagnosis, and attachment patterns are not necessarily fixed.
Fraley (2019) reviewed developments in adult attachment research, highlighting the complexity of attachment processes and the ways they operate within close relationships.
Furthermore, Taylor et al. (2015) conducted a systematic review examining changes in adult attachment representations during psychological therapy. Their findings suggested that attachment security can increase following therapy, although the evidence concerning changes in attachment avoidance was less clear and further controlled research was needed.
This is important because it suggests that therapy can potentially help people develop more secure ways of relating.
Imagine a man who has spent years withdrawing whenever his partner becomes emotionally demanding.
He tells himself that he needs space.
He becomes uncomfortable when she asks him to talk about his feelings.
He experiences emotional intimacy as overwhelming.
Through counselling, he begins to recognise that his withdrawal is not simply a preference for independence. It is also a response to the discomfort he experiences when somebody gets close to him.
He begins to understand that he can experience discomfort without necessarily needing to escape the relationship.
He learns to communicate his need for space without abandoning the other person emotionally.
He begins to tolerate vulnerability.
This does not mean that he suddenly becomes a completely different person.
He may still need time alone. He may still experience discomfort during conflict. He may still have moments when his old patterns reappear.
But he has developed a greater capacity to respond differently.
And I think this is an important distinction.
Change does not necessarily mean that the old pattern disappears. Sometimes it means that the person develops a greater capacity to recognise it, regulate it and choose a different response.
This is something that I think boys and men in Reading and Berkshire would benefit from understanding.
You do not have to become a completely different person to develop healthier relationships.
But you do have to become willing to understand the ways in which your existing patterns may be affecting other people.
The man who becomes sober, but has he changed?
I think addiction provides one of the clearest examples of the complexity of psychological change. Think about a man living in Tilehurst who has spent years drinking heavily. His drinking has affected his relationships. He has missed birthdays, broken promises, lost employment and caused significant distress to the people around him.
Eventually, he becomes sober.
He attends recovery meetings. He develops a support network. He begins taking responsibility for his behaviour.
And perhaps he genuinely changes his relationship with alcohol.
But what happens to the other parts of his life?
What happens to the relationship with his partner, who spent years worrying about him?
What happens to the children who learned to anticipate his behaviour?
What happens to the friendships that deteriorated?
What happens to the emotional wounds that remain, even after he has stopped drinking?
I think this is where we need to distinguish between recovery and relational repair.
Recovery may involve developing a healthier relationship with substances, understanding triggers, managing cravings and developing new coping strategies.
Relational repair involves something else.
It requires the person to recognise the impact of their behaviour on others, acknowledge the harm they caused and demonstrate that they are now capable of relating differently.
A man may be sober for five years and still struggle to understand why his partner does not trust him.
He may become frustrated that she continues to bring up the past.
He may say, “I’ve changed. I’ve stopped drinking. What more do you want from me?”
But from her perspective, the issue may not be whether he is drinking today.
It may be whether she feels safe trusting him again.
And this is where I think the conversation about change becomes particularly important.
Because the person who has changed and the person who experienced the harm may be at very different stages of their psychological journey.
The man may be ready to move forward.
The woman may still be trying to understand what happened.
Neither experience necessarily invalidates the other.
But the fact that he has changed does not automatically mean that she has healed.
And the fact that she has not healed does not necessarily mean that his change is false.
Both things can be true.
This is one of the reasons why I think we need to be careful about the language of forgiveness.
Forgiveness is not a simple psychological transaction in which one person changes and the other person is then expected to release them from the consequences of their behaviour.
It is a deeply personal process, and it cannot be demanded.
When the person who caused the harm has changed, but the person who experienced it has not
I think this is perhaps the most difficult part of the entire conversation.
Imagine a man who was emotionally abusive in his twenties.
He regularly belittled his partner, dismissed her feelings and made her question her own judgement.
The relationship eventually ended.
Years later, he begins counselling. He develops insight into his behaviour. He recognises the impact of his actions and begins to understand how his own experiences of shame, rejection and emotional insecurity contributed to the way he behaved.
He changes.
He enters another relationship and behaves differently.
He becomes a loving father.
He develops a much healthier relationship with himself.
But the woman he hurt is still struggling.
She has experienced difficulties trusting men. She has become anxious in relationships. She sometimes questions her own judgement.
And perhaps she has spent years in therapy trying to understand what happened.
Now, imagine that the man encounters her again.
He wants to apologise.
He wants her to know that he is no longer the person he used to be.
He wants forgiveness.
But what does she owe him?
I think we need to ask this question because we sometimes place an enormous amount of emphasis on the rehabilitation of the person who caused harm, while paying considerably less attention to the experience of the person who was harmed.
We celebrate the man who has changed.
We praise his recovery.
We admire his growth.
But what happens to the woman who is still living with the consequences of his behaviour?
Does she have to forgive him because he has changed?
Does she have to acknowledge his growth?
Does she have to give him another opportunity to demonstrate that he is different?
I would argue that she does not.
A person can genuinely change and still not be entitled to forgiveness.
A person can become psychologically healthier and still not be entitled to access to somebody they previously harmed.
And a person can demonstrate genuine remorse without the person they hurt ever being required to participate in their rehabilitation.
This is an important distinction between psychological change and moral entitlement.
Changing your behaviour does not create an obligation for somebody else to change their feelings about you.
I think this is particularly important for men to understand.
Because sometimes, when a man begins to change, he expects the people around him to recognise that change immediately.
He may feel frustrated that his partner still remembers the things he did.
He may feel that his efforts are not being acknowledged.
He may believe that he has done everything necessary to move forward.
But part of becoming a healthier person may involve developing the capacity to tolerate the fact that somebody else is not ready to forgive you.
And perhaps that is one of the most difficult forms of emotional maturity.
To accept that you can become a better person without being entitled to a better relationship with the person you hurt.
The psychology of forgiveness: does forgiveness mean the harm is forgotten?
I think we need to distinguish between several different concepts that are often grouped together.
There is forgiveness.
There is reconciliation.
There is accountability.
There is rehabilitation.
And there is the restoration of trust.
These are not the same thing.
Forgiveness may involve a person’s internal process of working through resentment, anger or emotional pain.
Reconciliation involves the possibility of restoring a relationship.
Accountability involves acknowledging responsibility for one’s behaviour and its consequences.
Rehabilitation involves developing the capacity to live and behave differently.
Trust involves an assessment of whether somebody is likely to behave in a reliable and safe way in the future.
A person may forgive somebody without reconciling with them.
A person may reconcile with somebody while still having difficulties trusting them.
A person may demonstrate genuine rehabilitation without ever being forgiven.
And a person may express remorse without having demonstrated meaningful change.
This is why I think the question of forgiveness becomes particularly complicated when we are talking about serious harm.
Because forgiveness cannot simply be treated as evidence that the person who caused the harm has changed.
Nor can the absence of forgiveness automatically be treated as evidence that they have not.
In counselling, we may explore forgiveness as part of a client’s healing process, but it should not be imposed as a therapeutic objective.
For some people, healing may involve forgiveness.
For others, healing may involve establishing boundaries, reclaiming their identity, processing grief, developing a sense of safety and accepting that the person who harmed them may never fully acknowledge what happened.
And I think we need to respect that.
The person who experienced harm should not have to forgive somebody in order to demonstrate that they have healed.
Equally, the person who caused harm should not be encouraged to believe that their rehabilitation depends entirely on receiving forgiveness from somebody else.
There is a difference between taking responsibility for your behaviour and making another person responsible for your recovery.
And I think this is something that we need to teach men.
Forensic psychology: when change becomes a question of public safety
There is another dimension to this conversation that I think is particularly important.
When we are talking about people who have caused harm, we are not always talking about something that can be resolved through personal reflection, counselling or forgiveness.
Sometimes there are legal consequences.
Sometimes there are safeguarding concerns.
Sometimes there are patterns of behaviour that create an ongoing risk to other people.
And this is where forensic psychology becomes particularly relevant.
Forensic psychology is concerned with the relationship between psychological functioning and the legal system. It can involve understanding offending behaviour, assessing risk, supporting rehabilitation and examining the psychological factors that may contribute to harmful behaviour.
One of the important distinctions in forensic psychology is the difference between understanding risk and predicting an individual’s behaviour with absolute certainty.
Risk assessment is not about determining whether somebody is a good or bad person.
It involves examining factors associated with the likelihood of future harmful behaviour, alongside the person’s circumstances, strengths, protective factors and capacity for change.
This is particularly important when we are discussing sexual offending.
There is a temptation to approach the subject through two extremes.
One position is that people who commit sexual offences are permanently dangerous and incapable of change.
The other is that people who have changed their behaviour should automatically be considered safe.
Neither position adequately reflects the complexity of the evidence.
A 2023 updated meta-analysis by Schmucker and colleagues examined treatment outcomes among people with histories of sexual offending. The review included 37 samples and more than 30,000 individuals. It found an overall treatment effect indicating lower sexual recidivism among treated individuals, although the effect was modest and varied according to factors including risk level and treatment specialisation.
This is important because it demonstrates that rehabilitation is a meaningful area of research and practice.
But it also highlights why we cannot simply assume that a person has changed because they have entered therapy, developed a new identity or begun a new relationship.
In forensic contexts, change needs to be evaluated carefully.
We need to consider the person’s behaviour over time, their understanding of the harm they caused, their willingness to accept responsibility, their engagement with treatment and the factors that may increase or reduce the likelihood of future harm.
And I think there is an important lesson here for our everyday relationships as well.
When a man tells you that he has changed, it is reasonable to ask what that change actually looks like.
Not because we should assume that he is lying.
But because change is something that needs to be understood through more than a person’s account of themselves.
A man may genuinely believe that he has changed.
But his understanding of his own behaviour may still be incomplete.
He may have developed insight into some aspects of his behaviour while remaining unaware of others.
He may have changed in one relationship while continuing to behave differently in another.
He may have stopped engaging in a particular behaviour without fully understanding the beliefs, emotions or circumstances that contributed to it.
This does not mean that his change is necessarily false.
It means that change is complex, and we need to evaluate it with care.
Russell Brand, public identity and the question of transformation
Returning to Russell Brand, I think there is something particularly interesting about the relationship between public identity and psychological change.
Brand has spoken publicly about his history of addiction, his recovery and his Christian faith. His public identity has changed considerably over the years.
But I think we need to distinguish between the development of a public identity and the development of a psychologically integrated self.
A person may genuinely experience a religious conversion.
They may develop a new sense of purpose.
They may begin to understand their past through a different moral framework.
They may experience a profound shift in their relationship with themselves.
But none of these things automatically establishes whether they have changed in the ways that matter to the people they have previously harmed.
This is not a criticism of religion.
In fact, I think religion can provide a powerful framework for psychological change.
For some people, religious belief can create a sense of meaning, community, accountability and connection that was previously absent from their lives.
But religious transformation and psychological transformation are not necessarily identical.
A person can experience a genuine spiritual awakening while continuing to struggle with aspects of their psychological functioning.
Equally, a person can develop considerable psychological maturity without experiencing a religious conversion.
The question is not whether somebody has become religious.
The question is whether their beliefs are reflected in the way they treat other human beings.
And this is where I think the distinction between repentance and accountability becomes particularly important.
In many religious traditions, repentance involves recognising wrongdoing, turning away from it and attempting to live differently.
But repentance is not simply a declaration.
It involves a change in one’s relationship with the behaviour itself.
And perhaps the most meaningful evidence of that change is not how a person speaks about their transformation, but how they behave when they are confronted with the consequences of their past.
In the context of the ongoing Russell Brand trial, I think it is important to maintain this distinction.
Brand has denied the charges against him. His wife has given evidence about her experience of him as a husband and father. Brand has also spoken in court about his past behaviour and his views on consent.
Sky News+1
But the character reference provided by a spouse is not a clinical assessment of psychological change, nor is it a determination of whether the allegations are true or false.
A person can be experienced as caring and attentive within one relationship while other people describe very different experiences of them.
That is not necessarily a contradiction.
Human beings can behave differently in different relationships, and the experience of one person does not automatically establish the experience of another.
This is why I think we need to be cautious about using somebody’s present relationship as evidence of their entire character.
And it is why I think the question of change needs to be examined more carefully than simply asking whether somebody is now a good husband, a good father or a good Christian.
Those things may be meaningful.
But they are not the whole story.
The redemption narrative: when a man becomes the hero of his own story
There is another area of research that I think adds something particularly interesting to this conversation.
In criminology, Shadd Maruna’s work on desistance from crime examines how people who move away from criminal behaviour construct new understandings of themselves.
In his influential book Making Good: How Ex-Convicts Reform and Rebuild Their Lives (2001), Maruna explored the narratives of people who had successfully desisted from crime.
He found that many people who had moved away from offending developed what he described as a redemption narrative.
They began to understand their past behaviour as something that was inconsistent with the person they wanted to become.
They developed a new sense of identity.
They began to see themselves as capable of contributing positively to society.
And they developed a narrative that connected their past, present and future.
I think this is particularly interesting when we consider men who have experienced significant psychological change.
A man who previously struggled with addiction may begin to understand himself as somebody who has overcome adversity.
A man who previously engaged in criminal behaviour may begin to understand himself as somebody who has developed a different set of values.
A man who previously behaved abusively may begin to understand himself as somebody who is now committed to healthy relationships.
These narratives can be important.
They can provide a sense of meaning, purpose and motivation.
But I think there is a potential difficulty.
What happens when the redemption narrative becomes so important to the person’s identity that they struggle to acknowledge the harm they caused?
Imagine a man who has spent ten years rebuilding his life after addiction.
He has become sober.
He has developed a successful business.
He has become a father.
He has written a book about his recovery.
He now sees himself as somebody who has overcome his past.
But when his former partner talks about the emotional damage he caused, he becomes defensive.
He says, “That was years ago. I’ve changed.”
He begins to experience her account of the past as a threat to the person he has become.
And perhaps this is where the redemption narrative becomes psychologically complicated.
The man has developed a new identity, but he may struggle to integrate the fact that the person he was and the person he has become are both part of his life story.
He wants to be recognised for his transformation.
But he does not want to be reminded of the harm that preceded it.
I think this is where genuine psychological integration becomes particularly important.
A person does not necessarily need to remain trapped in shame about their past.
But they do need to be able to acknowledge it.
They need to be able to say:
“I was responsible for what I did.”
“I understand that my behaviour caused harm.”
“I recognise that the consequences of my behaviour may continue to affect other people.”
“I have worked to change, but I do not expect that change to erase what happened.”
And perhaps most importantly:
“I can acknowledge the person I have become without denying the person I was.”
That, to me, is a much more psychologically mature understanding of change.
What does genuine change look like in a man?
I think this is where we need to bring the conversation back to boys and men.
Because it is one thing to discuss personality development, attachment, rehabilitation and forgiveness.
But what does change actually look like in everyday life?
What would I look for if I were working with a man who wanted to understand whether he had genuinely changed?
I would be interested in several things.
1. The ability to take responsibility without collapsing into shame
There is a difference between guilt and shame.
Guilt can involve recognising that you have done something wrong.
Shame can involve experiencing yourself as fundamentally defective or unworthy.
A man who experiences overwhelming shame may struggle to acknowledge his behaviour because doing so threatens his entire sense of self.
He may become defensive.
He may minimise what happened.
He may blame other people.
He may attempt to move away from the conversation.
But psychological maturity involves developing the capacity to acknowledge wrongdoing without necessarily concluding that you are incapable of becoming a better person.
This is important because shame can sometimes become a barrier to accountability.
A man who believes that acknowledging his behaviour makes him a terrible person may struggle to remain emotionally present when confronted with the consequences of his actions.
The therapeutic work may involve helping him develop a more integrated understanding of himself.
He can recognise that he has caused harm without believing that he is permanently defined by it.
But equally, he cannot use his desire to avoid shame as a reason to avoid responsibility.
2. The ability to tolerate another person’s perspective
One of the things I would be particularly interested in is whether the man can tolerate hearing about the impact of his behaviour.
Can he listen when somebody tells him that he hurt them?
Can he remain present when their account of the relationship differs from his own?
Can he acknowledge that another person may have experienced something that he did not fully understand at the time?
This is particularly important when we are talking about emotional abuse, coercive control and harmful relationship patterns.
A man may have developed considerable insight into his own emotional experiences.
But if he remains unable to recognise the experiences of other people, his change may still be incomplete.
3. The ability to behave differently when he is emotionally activated
I think this is particularly important.
It is relatively easy to demonstrate emotional maturity when everything is going well.
It is much more difficult when you feel rejected, humiliated, criticised, abandoned or threatened.
A man may be loving and attentive when he feels secure.
But what happens when his partner disagrees with him?
What happens when he feels that he is losing control?
What happens when somebody challenges his beliefs?
What happens when he does not get what he wants?
These are the situations in which we begin to see whether the person has developed a different capacity for emotional regulation.
Change is not simply about behaving differently when the circumstances are favourable.
It is about developing the capacity to respond differently when the circumstances are difficult.
4. The ability to recognise that change is ongoing
I think this is another important distinction.
A man who has genuinely changed does not necessarily believe that he has reached a point at which he no longer needs to reflect on himself.
He recognises that he is still capable of making mistakes.
He understands that his old patterns may reappear under stress.
He remains willing to examine his behaviour.
He does not assume that his previous therapeutic work makes him immune to future difficulties.
And perhaps this is one of the most important aspects of psychological maturity.
The ability to remain open to the possibility that you still have something to learn about yourself.
What does this mean for boys and men in Reading and Berkshire?
I think this conversation is particularly important for young men.
Because so many boys grow up believing that their behaviour is simply an expression of who they are.
They are told that they are aggressive.
They are told that they are emotionally unavailable.
They are told that they are difficult.
They are told that they are immature.
And sometimes, they begin to believe that these descriptions are permanent.
But I think we need to offer boys and men a different understanding of psychological development.
You can learn to regulate your emotions.
You can develop greater emotional awareness.
You can learn to communicate more effectively.
You can develop healthier attachment patterns.
You can understand the impact of your behaviour on other people.
You can move away from addiction.
You can develop healthier relationships.
You can become a different kind of father, partner, friend or man.
But none of this happens simply because you want it to.
It requires work.
Sometimes that work involves counselling.
Sometimes it involves recovery programmes.
Sometimes it involves developing healthier friendships.
Sometimes it involves learning to tolerate emotions that you have spent years avoiding.
And sometimes it involves acknowledging that the people you hurt may never be able to offer you the forgiveness you want.
For men in Reading and Berkshire, I think there is an important opportunity to begin having these conversations much earlier.
We need to teach boys that emotional regulation is not weakness.
We need to teach them that accountability is not humiliation.
We need to teach them that masculinity does not have to involve emotional suppression, entitlement or control.
We need to teach them that being a man does not mean being incapable of change.
And we need to teach them that becoming a healthier person involves more than simply feeling better about themselves.
It also involves developing the capacity to relate to other people in healthier ways.
At Male Minds Counselling, this is one of the things I am particularly interested in exploring with men.
Not simply what has happened to you.
Not simply why you behave the way you do.
But what kind of man you want to become, what is getting in the way of that development and how you begin to make those changes in your everyday life.
Because I think the question of change is ultimately a question about responsibility.
What are you willing to take responsibility for?
What are you willing to understand about yourself?
What are you willing to do differently?
And what happens when the person you want to become requires you to acknowledge things about the person you have been?
So, do people truly change?
I think the research suggests that they can.
Personality can change.
Attachment patterns can change.
People can develop greater emotional regulation.
People can recover from addiction.
People can move away from criminal behaviour.
People can develop healthier relationships.
People can become more emotionally available, more compassionate and more capable of recognising the experiences of other people.
But I think we need to be careful about what we mean when we say that somebody has changed.
Because change is not simply about becoming a different person.
It is also about developing a different relationship with the person you used to be.
It is about acknowledging your past without allowing it to determine your future.
It is about recognising that the people you hurt may continue to live with the consequences of your behaviour.
It is about understanding that your growth does not automatically erase their pain.
And it is about accepting that forgiveness is not something you can demand from another person.
Perhaps this is where I have arrived in my thinking.
I believe that people can change.
But I also believe that genuine change requires a willingness to acknowledge the past, rather than simply move away from it.
A man can become a better person.
He can become a healthier partner.
He can become a more present father.
He can become more emotionally mature.
He can develop a different understanding of himself.
But he cannot rewrite the experiences of the people he hurt.
And perhaps he does not need to.
Perhaps the task is not to erase the past, but to develop the capacity to live differently in the present.
To become somebody who no longer needs to repeat the same patterns.
To become somebody who can acknowledge the harm he caused without becoming defensive.
To become somebody who understands that his growth is meaningful, even if it does not result in forgiveness.
And perhaps the most important question is not simply whether people change.
Perhaps it is this:
When you have changed, are you willing to take responsibility for the person you used to be, and for the people who had to live with him?
That, I think, is where the real work begins.
Research and literature
Personality development and psychological change
Roberts, B.W., Walton, K.E. and Viechtbauer, W. (2006) ‘Patterns of mean-level change in personality traits across the life course: A meta-analysis of longitudinal studies’, Psychological Bulletin, 132(1), pp. 1–25. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.132.1.1
Roberts, B.W., Luo, J., Briley, D.A., Chow, P.I., Su, R. and Hill, P.L. (2017) ‘A systematic review of personality trait change through intervention’, Psychological Bulletin, 143(2), pp. 117–141. https://doi.org/10.1037/bul0000088
Attachment and psychotherapy
Fraley, R.C. (2019) ‘Attachment in adulthood: Recent developments, emerging debates, and future directions’, Annual Review of Psychology, 70, pp. 401–422. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-010418-102813
Taylor, P., Rietzschel, J., Danquah, A. and Berry, K. (2015) ‘Changes in attachment representations during psychological therapy’, Psychotherapy Research, 25(2), pp. 222–238. https://doi.org/10.1080/10503307.2014.886791
Desistance, rehabilitation and identity
Laub, J.H. and Sampson, R.J. (1993) ‘Turning points in the life course: Why change matters to the study of crime’, Criminology, 31(3), pp. 301–325. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1745-9125.1993.tb01132.x
Maruna, S. (2001) Making Good: How Ex-Convicts Reform and Rebuild Their Lives. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
Maruna, S. (2025) ‘Redeeming desistance: From individual journeys to a social movement’, Criminology, 63(1), pp. 5–25. https://doi.org/10.1111/1745-9125.12393
Forensic psychology and treatment
Schmucker, M., Lösel, F. and colleagues (2023) ‘Moderators of sexual recidivism as indicator of treatment effectiveness in persons with sexual offense histories: An updated meta-analysis’, Sexual Abuse. https://doi.org/10.1177/10790632231159071
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2009) Antisocial Personality Disorder: Prevention and Management. Clinical guideline CG77. Available at: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg77
