Voltaire once said that“Every man is a creature of the age in which he lives and few are able to raise themselves above the ideas of the time. The quote suggests that our thoughts, values, morals, and perceptions are deeply shaped by the social, political, and intellectual climate of the era we are born into. Most people unconsciously absorb the biases and assumptions of their surroundings. Only a small minority of critical thinkers, reformers, and free-thinkers manage to step outside the mental boundaries of their generation and question prevailing norms. There is a conversation taking place about relationships, marriage, masculinity and the changing expectations of men and women that I think is asking that men raise themselves above the ideas of the time. Particularly for young men growing up today, because much of what is happening in adult relationships did not suddenly appear when somebody turned 30, 40 or 50. In many cases, the foundations were laid much earlier, during childhood, adolescence and the process of learning what it means to be a boy.
If it is not smacking you in the face already; women have undergone a significant cultural transformation over the last 50 years, whereas many of the expectations placed on men have remained relatively unchanged. Women have increasingly entered the workforce, gained financial independence, challenged traditional gender roles and become less dependent on marriage for economic security. They have also become more vocal about what they expect from intimate relationships.
Men, however, are often still operating with an emotional blueprint inherited from a different generation.
This creates a significant problem. Women are increasingly asking for emotional intimacy, communication, vulnerability, equality and partnership, while many men have been raised to value independence, emotional control, self-sufficiency and invulnerability.
In other words, we are asking people to build a different kind of relationship using skills that many of them were never taught.
I think this is particularly important for young men in Reading to understand. Whether you are 16, 21, 25 or 35, you are growing up in a world where the expectations of relationships are changing. You might have watched your father, grandfather or other male relatives operate within a particular understanding of masculinity. You might have seen men who worked hard, paid the bills, provided for their families and believed that these things were sufficient expressions of love.
But your generation is increasingly being asked to do something different.
You are being asked not only to provide, but to participate emotionally. Not only to protect, but to communicate. Not only to be strong, but to be emotionally available. Not only to remain in a relationship, but to contribute to the quality of that relationship. You are being asked to make an effort as a default. And not be thanked for it, since women have been doing it for years as a default.
And if nobody has helped you understand the difference, you can find yourself feeling criticised, inadequate, confused or even threatened by expectations that your partner considers perfectly reasonable.
To understand why this happens, we need to go back to childhood.
The changing expectations of men and women
One of the central observations I have noticed, is that women have changed considerably, but men have not necessarily experienced the same cultural transformation.
Historically, marriage served several purposes. It provided economic security, social acceptance, financial stability, companionship and, in many circumstances, a degree of protection for women who had limited opportunities to support themselves independently.
For previous generations, a woman might have remained in a marriage because leaving would have meant financial hardship, social judgement, religious condemnation or losing access to the resources needed to raise her children.
This does not mean that every traditional marriage was unhappy or that previous generations did not experience love. Many couples built meaningful, lifelong relationships. However, the expectations placed on husbands and wives were often considerably different from those we have today.
A husband might have considered himself a good man because he worked, provided financially, remained faithful and did not physically abuse his wife.
A wife might have been expected to accept that her husband was not particularly communicative, emotionally expressive or interested in discussing the relationship.
This was a companionable marriage. Two people share a household, raise children, fulfil their responsibilities and maintain a relatively stable family structure. They might care about each other, but that does not necessarily mean they experience emotional intimacy.
Today, many women want something more.
They want to feel emotionally understood. They want to have difficult conversations without being dismissed. They want affection, sexual connection, shared responsibilities, friendship and the feeling that their partner is genuinely interested in who they are becoming.
They want to be able to sit with their husbands and discuss their fears, ambitions, disappointments and experiences without feeling that they are inconveniencing them.
They want to remain lovers, not simply become two people who manage a mortgage, children, household responsibilities and family commitments.
This is an important distinction.
Being in a relationship and experiencing intimacy within a relationship are not the same thing.
A couple can live together for 30 years and know very little about each other’s internal worlds.
A man might know what his wife likes to eat, when she needs collecting from work, what medication she takes and which bills need paying. Yet he might struggle to answer questions such as:
- What is she currently worried about?
- What makes her feel emotionally secure?
- What has she been disappointed about recently?
- What does she need more of from me?
- What does she feel she has sacrificed?
- When was the last time I genuinely asked her how she was feeling and listened without becoming defensive?
Equally, a woman might know that her husband works hard, provides for the family and takes care of practical responsibilities, but have very little understanding of what he is emotionally carrying.
The problem is not necessarily an absence of love. Sometimes it is an absence of the skills required to communicate that love. And this is where things become particularly interesting for men all over Reading.
The disconnected boy: How boys learn to abandon their emotional worlds
One of the most important arguments I have is that boys are not necessarily born emotionally disconnected.
In fact, I challenge the assumption that boys naturally develop into less emotionally expressive human beings than girls.
Think about a little boy.
He cries when he is frightened. He reaches for his mother when he is upset. He wants affection, reassurance, comfort and attention. He might become distressed when somebody leaves him. He wants to be held, kissed and told that everything is going to be alright.
He has emotional needs just like anybody else.
There is nothing inherently wrong with this.
However, as boys grow older, they begin receiving messages about which emotions are acceptable and which ones are not.
Some of these messages are explicit:
“Stop crying.”
“Man up.”
“Don’t be a girl.”
“Big boys don’t cry.”
“You’re too sensitive.”
“Don’t let them see you upset.”
“Sort yourself out.”
Others are more subtle.
A boy might notice that his father becomes uncomfortable when he cries. He might see his mother respond differently to his sister’s emotional distress. He might observe that boys who appear confident, physically strong and emotionally unaffected receive greater approval from their peers.
He learns through watching, listening and experiencing the consequences of his behaviour.
Eventually, he starts to understand that certain parts of himself receive approval, while other parts attract embarrassment, criticism or rejection.
This is socialisation.
It is not necessarily something that happens through one conversation or one significant event. It is often a gradual process involving hundreds of small interactions.
A boy who cries after being bullied might be told to toughen up. A boy who admits that he is frightened might be laughed at. A boy who tells his friends that he misses his mother might be called childish.
Over time, he begins to associate vulnerability with humiliation.
He learns that being emotionally open carries a social cost.
And so he adapts.
He might become quieter about his feelings. He might use humour to deflect uncomfortable conversations. He might become aggressive when he feels embarrassed. He might pretend that things do not bother him.
Eventually, he might become a young man who genuinely struggles to identify what he is feeling.
This is important because there is a difference between not having emotions and not having the language, confidence or permission to express them.
A young man might tell you:
“I don’t really know how I feel.”
“I’m just tired.”
“I can’t be bothered with all that emotional stuff.”
“I don’t like talking about my problems.”
“What’s the point? Nothing changes anyway.”
Sometimes these statements are genuine preferences. Sometimes, however, they are protective strategies developed over many years.
The young man has learned that emotional disclosure is uncomfortable, potentially embarrassing and sometimes dangerous to his sense of identity.
He has not necessarily stopped feeling. He has learned to conceal what he feels.
The difference between emotional regulation and emotional suppression
This distinction is particularly important.
Emotional regulation is the ability to recognise an emotion, understand what has triggered it and respond in a way that does not cause unnecessary harm to yourself or other people.
Emotional suppression is the attempt to push an emotion away, deny its existence or prevent other people from seeing it.
These are not the same thing.
A man who can experience anger without becoming violent is demonstrating emotional regulation.
A man who feels angry but refuses to acknowledge it, becomes increasingly resentful and eventually explodes at his partner might be demonstrating emotional suppression rather than emotional strength.
Similarly, a man who can acknowledge that he is frightened, discuss what is worrying him and make a sensible decision is not weak.
He is emotionally competent.
We need to stop confusing the absence of emotional expression with the presence of emotional strength.
A man who never cries might be emotionally resilient. He might also be frightened of what would happen if he allowed himself to cry.
You cannot determine somebody’s psychological health simply by how little emotion they display.
The wound to boys and the wound to girls: Two different forms of disconnection
One of the most interesting parts of this, is to draw upon the work of Carol Gilligan.
Gilligan’s work challenged traditional psychological theories that treated male experiences as the universal standard against which female development should be measured.
Her research explored how girls and women develop their identities, moral voices and relationships within a culture that often rewards them for being accommodating, agreeable and attentive to other people’s needs.
There are two different psychological wounds that can emerge through traditional gender socialisation.
The wound to girls is described as disempowerment.
The wound to boys is described as disconnection.
I think this distinction provides a useful framework for understanding why men and women can arrive in adult relationships with very different emotional difficulties.
It is important, though, not to treat these as universal characteristics of all boys and girls. Gender socialisation varies considerably across families, cultures, socioeconomic circumstances and individual personalities. Boys can experience disempowerment, and girls can experience emotional disconnection. These are patterns to explore, not rigid categories.
Nevertheless, the contrast is worth examining.
The girl: Learning to accommodate everybody else
Traditionally, girls have often been rewarded for being pleasant, helpful, considerate, cooperative and emotionally attentive.
They might be praised for being mature, responsible and well behaved.
They are encouraged to think about how other people feel, avoid unnecessary conflict and maintain relationships.
On the surface, these are positive qualities.
There is nothing wrong with kindness, consideration or compromise.
The problem emerges when a girl learns that her acceptance depends upon consistently putting other people’s needs before her own.
She begins to understand that being a good girl means not causing problems.
She might learn to say yes when she wants to say no. She might agree with something because she does not want to upset somebody. She might hide her disappointment because she does not want to appear ungrateful.
She becomes very good at reading other people’s emotions but increasingly disconnected from her own.
This can create the tyranny of the nice and kind.
The phrase is particularly powerful because it highlights how a socially desirable quality can become psychologically restrictive.
A girl might become so concerned with being liked, accepted and considered a good person that she loses the ability to communicate what she actually thinks.
She learns to prioritise harmony over honesty.
Consider a teenage girl who is uncomfortable with a boy’s behaviour towards her.
She might recognise that something is wrong but worry that challenging him will make her appear difficult, dramatic or unkind.
She might laugh at a joke she finds offensive. She might agree to something she does not really want. She might avoid expressing her discomfort because she does not want to create an argument.
This is not necessarily because she does not know what she wants.
It may be because she has learned that expressing what she wants comes with consequences.
Over time, this can contribute to resentment, anxiety, low self-esteem and difficulties establishing boundaries.
It can also contribute to people-pleasing in adult relationships.
A woman might spend years accommodating her partner, managing the household, organising family life, remembering birthdays, arranging childcare, maintaining relationships with relatives and anticipating everybody else’s emotional needs.
Eventually, she might reach a point where she thinks:
“When does somebody look after me?”
“Why am I always the one who has to think about everything?”
“Why do I have to explain something that should be obvious?”
“Why am I responsible for everybody else’s happiness?”
The frustration might appear to emerge suddenly, but the emotional history behind it could have been developing for decades.
The healing movement is re-empowerment.
Learning to speak honestly. Learning to say no. Learning to establish boundaries. Learning that disagreement does not automatically make somebody unkind.
Learning that you can love somebody without abandoning yourself.
The boy: Learning to disconnect from himself
The traditional wound described for boys is different.
Rather than being primarily encouraged to accommodate others, boys are often encouraged to become independent, emotionally controlled and self-sufficient.
They are taught to minimise vulnerability and demonstrate strength.
They might learn to prioritise achievement, competence, physical confidence and problem-solving.
Again, these are not inherently negative qualities.
The problem emerges when independence becomes an inability to depend on anybody, emotional control becomes emotional suppression and strength becomes an inability to admit that something hurts.
A boy might learn to hide his sadness rather than communicate it.
He might learn to turn embarrassment into anger.
He might learn to deal with rejection by pretending he never cared.
He might learn to withdraw when somebody asks him to explain his feelings.
He might become increasingly uncomfortable with emotional conversations because he has never developed the vocabulary or confidence to participate in them.
The result can be a young man who appears independent but struggles with emotional intimacy.
He might be able to discuss football, money, work, cars, business, fitness, sex or current affairs quite comfortably.
But ask him:
“Are you happy?”
“What are you frightened of?”
“Do you feel loved?”
“What do you need from the people around you?”
“What happens inside you when somebody rejects you?”
And suddenly, he might struggle.
Not because he is unintelligent.
Not because he does not care.
But because these are conversations he has not necessarily been taught how to have.
The healing movement for boys as reconnection.
Reconnecting with their feelings, their hearts and the people they love.
I think that is one of the most important messages for young men to take away.
The task is not to become less masculine. It is to stop abandoning parts of yourself in order to perform masculinity.
Two different wounds, two different healing movements
The traditional wound to girls
Disempowerment
- Over-accommodation
- People-pleasing
- Loss of voice
- Suppressed anger
- Resentment
- Difficulty establishing boundaries
Healing: Re-empowerment
Finding their voice, expressing needs and learning to put themselves first when necessary.
The traditional wound to boys
Disconnection
- Emotional suppression
- Fear of vulnerability
- Isolation
- Difficulty expressing needs
- Defensive behaviour
- Emotional withdrawal
Healing: Reconnection
Reconnecting with feelings, relationships, emotional needs and the ability to receive support.
There is something particularly important here for parents, teachers, coaches and people working with young people.
We often focus on teaching girls to be confident, assertive and independent.
We need to do the same for boys emotionally.
And we need to teach girls that being considerate does not mean being responsible for everybody else’s happiness.
Neither child should have to sacrifice their psychological development to fulfil somebody else’s expectations of gender.
Why the disconnected boy becomes the disconnected man
There is a sentence that deserves particular attention: “The cost of a disconnected boy is a disconnected man.”
It is a relatively simple statement, but it has considerable psychological implications.
Childhood experiences do not automatically determine adult outcomes. People change, develop new relationships, receive support and learn different ways of responding to the world.
However, the emotional strategies developed during childhood can become deeply familiar.
If a boy repeatedly learns that talking about his feelings leads to embarrassment, he might carry that expectation into adolescence.
If he experiences vulnerability as something that threatens his social standing, he might become increasingly guarded in his friendships.
If he learns that asking for help is a sign of weakness, he might avoid seeking support when he experiences anxiety, depression, bereavement or relationship difficulties.
Eventually, these strategies can become part of how he understands himself.
He might describe himself as somebody who does not need anybody.
He might pride himself on being able to deal with everything independently.
He might say that he does not like drama, does not talk about feelings and prefers to keep things to himself.
But what happens when he enters an intimate relationship?
What happens when a woman wants to know what he is thinking?
What happens when she asks him to talk about something that has upset her?
What happens when she tells him that she feels emotionally disconnected?
What happens when she says:
“I don’t feel like you let me in.”
“You never tell me what’s going on.”
“I feel like I’m living with somebody who doesn’t know me.”
“I don’t want to have to keep asking you to communicate.”
He might experience these statements as criticism rather than invitations to reconnect.
He might become defensive, withdraw, change the subject or become angry.
His partner might interpret this as a lack of interest.
He might interpret her continued attempts to communicate as nagging or criticism.
And the cycle continues.
The emotional withdrawal cycle
Consider the following example.
A young man in Reading has been with his girlfriend for three years.
He works hard, goes to the gym, spends time with his friends and believes he is a good boyfriend.
His girlfriend tells him that she feels emotionally distant from him.
She says they do not have meaningful conversations anymore. She feels that he only talks to her about practical matters and that whenever she raises something difficult, he shuts down.
He becomes frustrated.
In his mind, he is doing everything he is supposed to do.
He has not cheated. He does not go out drinking every weekend. He pays his share of the bills. He takes her places. He has never hit her.
So why is she complaining?
He responds:
“You’re always finding something wrong.”
“Nothing I do is ever good enough.”
“Why can’t we just enjoy ourselves?”
She becomes more frustrated because she feels that he has not listened.
She raises the issue again.
He withdraws further.
She becomes increasingly anxious about the future of the relationship.
He feels increasingly criticised.
Eventually, both people feel misunderstood.
From his perspective, she is constantly dissatisfied.
From her perspective, he is emotionally unavailable.
Neither feels particularly loved.
This is where we need to understand something about attachment, emotional development and relationship patterns.
Sometimes, what appears to be an argument about communication is actually an argument about emotional safety.
One person is trying to establish connection.
The other is trying to protect themselves from the discomfort of emotional exposure.
The more one pursues, the more the other withdraws.
The more one withdraws, the more the other pursues.
This can resemble what attachment researchers and relationship therapists describe as a pursuer-distancer dynamic.
It is not exclusive to heterosexual couples or to men and women. Either partner can occupy either position.
But it is a particularly useful framework for understanding the difficulties that can arise when one partner has a greater appetite for emotional discussion and the other has learned to manage distress through withdrawal.
Why some men experience criticism as humiliation
Another particularly important part of this concerns male self-esteem. I think many men will recognise, even if they have never previously understood it. That many men have been taught to base their sense of worth on their performance.
In other words:
I am valuable because of what I achieve.
I am respected because of what I provide.
I am a good man because I am successful.
I am worthy because I am competent.
I am masculine because I am strong.
I am important because people need me.
There is nothing wrong with wanting to be successful, provide for your family, develop your career or become financially independent.
These are perfectly reasonable ambitions.
The psychological difficulty emerges when your entire sense of self-worth becomes dependent upon maintaining that performance.
Because eventually, you will fail at something.
You might lose your job.
You might experience financial difficulties.
You might struggle sexually.
You might make a parenting mistake.
You might disappoint somebody you love.
You might discover that you are not as emotionally mature as you believed.
And if your self-esteem depends upon always being competent, successful and respected, these experiences can feel like an attack on your identity.
This is where the distinction between shame and guilt becomes particularly useful.
Shame versus guilt
Guilt is generally concerned with behaviour.
“I did something wrong.”
“I hurt somebody.”
“I made a mistake.”
“I need to take responsibility.”
Shame is concerned with identity.
“I am a failure.”
“I’m useless.”
“I’m not good enough.”
“There’s something fundamentally wrong with me.”
Of course, shame and guilt are more complex than this distinction, and they can overlap. However, it is a useful way of understanding the emotional reactions that sometimes occur when somebody receives criticism.
Imagine a woman telling her partner:
“When you shouted at me in front of your friends, I felt humiliated. I need you to understand why that was hurtful.”
A man with a relatively secure sense of self might feel uncomfortable, embarrassed or guilty.
He might respond:
“I didn’t realise how much that affected you. I shouldn’t have spoken to you like that. I’m sorry.”
He can recognise that he behaved badly without concluding that he is a fundamentally bad person.
But a man whose self-esteem is heavily dependent on his performance might experience the conversation differently.
He hears:
“You’re not a good man.”
“You’re a failure.”
“You’re not the husband you should be.”
“You’re not good enough.”
He might not consciously interpret the conversation in these exact words, but the emotional experience can resemble this.
And because he cannot tolerate the feeling of being inadequate, he starts defending himself.
He might say:
“Well, you embarrassed me first.”
“You always make me look bad.”
“You’re too sensitive.”
“Why are you bringing this up now?”
“You’re acting like I’m some terrible person.”
Notice what has happened.
The original issue was his behaviour.
The conversation has now become an argument about whether he is a good person.
The partner is no longer discussing the original hurt. She is defending her right to raise it.
And he is defending his sense of worth.
This is one reason why accountability can become so difficult.
Healthy self-esteem and accountability
Remember that healthy self-esteem means being able to hold yourself in warm regard while recognising that you have behaved badly.
You can accept that you are a person of worth and still take responsibility for your actions.
You do not need to destroy yourself psychologically to acknowledge that you have hurt somebody.
This is particularly important for young men.
You are going to make mistakes in relationships.
You will sometimes say the wrong thing. You might become defensive. You might fail to recognise somebody else’s emotional needs. You might behave selfishly or avoid a difficult conversation.
The question is not whether you will make mistakes.
The question is whether you can recognise them, take responsibility and do something differently.
There is a difference between saying:
“I am a terrible person.”
And saying: “I behaved terribly, and I need to take responsibility for that.”
The first can lead to shame and avoidance.
The second creates the possibility of change.
A man who cannot tolerate being wrong will struggle to build a healthy relationship because intimacy requires the ability to receive feedback.
You cannot expect somebody to be emotionally honest with you if every difficult conversation becomes a battle over your self-esteem.
Accountability is not humiliation. It is the ability to remain responsible without abandoning your sense of personal worth.
Why women sometimes reach a point where they simply stop trying
There is another part that deserves attention, particularly when considering long-term relationships and what is sometimes described as grey divorce.
Grey divorce generally refers to divorce among older adults, often involving couples aged 50 and above.
Women reach a stage in midlife when they become less willing to accommodate their partners and more interested in pursuing their own identities, needs and independence.
The speaker connects this to menopause and changes in women’s experiences during midlife.
There are several things worth separating here.
Menopause is a biological transition involving significant hormonal changes. It can affect sleep, mood, cognition, sexual functioning and emotional wellbeing. However, it would be an oversimplification to suggest that menopause automatically rewires every woman’s brain in the same way or makes women inherently less accommodating.
The psychological experience of menopause is influenced by biological, relational, social and individual factors.
Nevertheless, midlife can become a significant period of psychological reassessment.
A woman might begin questioning the roles she has occupied throughout her life.
She might ask herself:
“Who am I outside of being somebody’s wife?”
“What have I sacrificed?”
“Have I spent 20 years making everybody else happy?”
“What do I actually want from the next 20 years of my life?”
“Am I happy in this marriage?”
“Do I want to continue living like this?”
These are not necessarily new questions.
They might be questions that have been present for many years but were previously pushed aside.
For example, imagine a woman who married at 24.
She had children, built a career, managed a household and supported her husband’s ambitions.
She might have spent years organising family life, remembering important dates, managing childcare, maintaining relationships with relatives and trying to keep everybody happy.
Her husband might consider himself a good man.
He has worked hard. He has provided financially. He has never been unfaithful.
But perhaps he has rarely asked her how she feels.
Perhaps he has not taken an equal responsibility for the emotional and practical work of family life.
Perhaps their sex life disappeared years ago.
Perhaps every attempt to discuss their relationship ended with an argument.
Perhaps she has spent years feeling lonely while living with somebody.
At 55, she might finally decide that she does not want to spend the next 20 years feeling the same way.
From her husband’s perspective, the decision might appear sudden.
He might say:
“I don’t understand where this has come from.”
“We’ve been together for 30 years.”
“I thought we were happy.”
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
But from her perspective, she might have been communicating her unhappiness for years.
The difference is that he might not have recognised the significance of what she was saying.
This is where the concept of emotional labour becomes important.
Emotional labour within relationships
Emotional labour in intimate relationships can include the work involved in recognising, anticipating and responding to emotional needs.
It can involve:
- Remembering what is important to your partner.
- Recognising when something is bothering them.
- Initiating difficult conversations.
- Maintaining emotional connection.
- Managing conflict.
- Supporting children through emotional difficulties.
- Maintaining relationships with extended family.
- Noticing when responsibilities are becoming unequal.
- Making sure that the relationship itself receives attention.
In some heterosexual relationships, women end up carrying a disproportionate amount of this responsibility.
They become the emotional managers of the household.
They are expected to know when the children are struggling, when a relative is upset, when a birthday is approaching, when a family member needs support and when the relationship needs attention.
The difficulty is that this work is often invisible.
A man might genuinely believe that he contributes equally because he does his share of the practical tasks.
But his partner might feel that she is still responsible for identifying what needs doing, asking him to do it and checking whether it has been done.
This is sometimes described as the mental load.
The important question for men is not simply:
“Do I help around the house?”
It is: “Am I equally responsible for noticing, organising, remembering and managing the things that keep our family functioning?”
That is a different level of participation.
And it is worth understanding before you reach the stage of having a partner tell you that she is exhausted.
The emotional intimacy gap: What women are asking for and what men think they are being asked to do
How women can encourage men to become more emotionally open?
The response is not simply tell women to demand more from men.
Instead, I suggest that they need to recognise that many men are being asked to learn something they were actively discouraged from doing.
This is a valuable point.
Imagine growing up being told that a good man is independent, strong, logical and emotionally controlled.
Then, at 30, you enter a relationship with a woman who tells you that she wants you to be more vulnerable.
You might genuinely not understand what that means.
Does she want you to cry?
Does she want you to talk about your childhood?
Does she want you to tell her when you are frightened?
Does she want you to discuss your insecurities?
Does she want you to stop trying to solve problems and simply listen?
Does she want you to become more emotionally expressive?
For some men, the request itself can feel like being asked to abandon the identity they have spent years constructing.
They might associate emotional openness with weakness, loss of control or humiliation.
They might also have had previous experiences where being vulnerable resulted in rejection, ridicule or having their disclosures used against them.
We need to acknowledge this without using it as an excuse for emotionally neglecting a partner.
A man’s history can help explain his behaviour.
It does not automatically justify the impact of that behaviour on somebody else.
There is a distinction between understanding why something is difficult and deciding that you do not have to work on it.
What emotional intimacy actually looks like
Emotional intimacy does not mean telling your partner absolutely everything.
It does not mean having to discuss your feelings every hour.
It does not mean losing your independence or becoming emotionally dependent upon somebody else.
It means developing the ability to allow another person to know you beyond your achievements, responsibilities and external presentation.
For example:
Instead of saying:
“I’m fine.”
You might say:
“I’ve had a difficult week at work, and I’m feeling quite overwhelmed. I haven’t really known how to talk about it.”
Instead of saying:
“Leave it. I don’t want to argue.”
You might say:
“I’m getting frustrated, and I don’t want to say something hurtful. Can we take 20 minutes and come back to this?”
Instead of saying:
“You’re always on my back.”
You might say:
“When you raise several things at once, I feel like I’m failing. I know that doesn’t mean you’re attacking me, but I struggle with it.”
Instead of saying:
“Nothing’s wrong.”
You might say:
“I’ve been feeling a little disconnected from you recently. I don’t know exactly what is happening, but I think we need to spend some time together.”
These are relatively small changes in language.
But they represent a significant change in emotional awareness.
You are moving from concealment towards communication.
From defensiveness towards reflection.
From emotional isolation towards connection.
8. Why men need to understand the difference between providing and participating
There is another traditional masculine expectation that needs examining.
Many men are raised to believe that their primary responsibility is to provide.
They should work hard, earn money, protect their families, maintain the household and ensure that their children have opportunities.
Again, there is nothing wrong with these ambitions.
But providing is not the same as participating emotionally.
A man can be financially successful and emotionally absent.
He can buy his children everything they need and still struggle to connect with them.
He can pay the mortgage and still leave his wife feeling lonely.
He can take his family on holiday and still be unable to have a meaningful conversation with his partner.
He can be physically present and psychologically unavailable.
This is particularly important for young men who are developing their understanding of fatherhood.
If you grew up with an absent father, an emotionally unavailable father or a father who struggled to communicate, you might have developed a particular understanding of what being a father means.
Perhaps you believe that being a good father means making sure your children never go without anything.
Perhaps you believe that being a good husband means earning enough money to provide a comfortable life.
Those things matter.
But your children also need to experience you.
They need to know that they can approach you when they are frightened.
They need to know that they can tell you when they have made a mistake.
They need to know that they can discuss relationships, sex, rejection, bullying, anxiety and disappointment without automatically receiving criticism.
They need to experience affection.
They need to see you apologise.
They need to see you take responsibility.
They need to understand that being a man does not mean being incapable of admitting that you are wrong.
And if you have a son, he needs to see that emotional expression is not something that belongs exclusively to women.
If you have a daughter, she needs to experience a father who listens, respects her boundaries and demonstrates that men can be emotionally safe.
This is how you begin changing the emotional inheritance passed between generations.
You do not need to become a perfect father.
You need to become a more emotionally available one.
The backlash against changing masculinity: Why some men feel threatened
As women’s independence has increased, there has been a cultural backlash in some areas against changing gender roles.
Some men feel that traditional masculinity is under attack.
They might interpret discussions about emotional intelligence, gender equality, consent, accountability and vulnerability as attempts to undermine men.
They might feel that society increasingly expects them to change while offering very little recognition of the difficulties they experience themselves.
Some of these frustrations deserve to be taken seriously.
Men experience loneliness, relationship breakdown, financial pressure, fatherhood difficulties, social isolation, unemployment, bereavement and mental health difficulties.
There are boys growing up without positive male role models.
There are men who feel that they have nobody to talk to.
There are fathers who feel disconnected from their children.
There are men who struggle to establish meaningful friendships.
There are men who have experienced abuse, rejection and trauma but have never felt able to discuss it.
These experiences deserve attention.
However, there is a difference between advocating for men’s wellbeing and using men’s difficulties to resist equality.
A man can advocate for better mental health support for boys without believing women should return to traditional domestic roles.
A man can acknowledge the difficulties fathers experience following separation without dismissing the importance of mothers’ experiences.
A man can discuss the challenges of modern dating without treating women as the enemy.
A man can challenge unfair expectations placed upon men without defending emotional unavailability, coercive behaviour or aggression.
The problem arises when a man interprets equality as the loss of his position rather than an opportunity to build healthier relationships.
If your identity depends upon having more authority, more control or greater importance than your partner, equality can feel threatening.
But if your identity is built upon being a secure, emotionally mature and responsible man, equality does not need to diminish you.
You do not become less of a man because a woman has her own career, financial independence, opinions and ambitions.
You do not become less masculine because you listen.
You do not become less powerful because you apologise.
You do not become less respected because you acknowledge your mistakes.
In fact, these qualities can make you a much better partner, father, friend and leader.
The relationship between vulnerability, connection and physical health
Emotional connection is not simply something women want from men.
It is also something men need.
I claim that there is potential longevity benefits of healthy relationships of more than 10 years.
The precise suggestion that a good relationship will automatically add ten years to your life should not be treated as a guaranteed medical outcome. However, there is substantial research associating social connection and supportive relationships with better health outcomes.
For example, research by Holt-Lunstad and colleagues has examined the relationship between social relationships and mortality risk.
Their findings have contributed to a wider understanding that social connection is not merely a lifestyle preference. It is an important factor in human wellbeing.
Similarly, the work of John Cacioppo explored the psychological and physiological consequences of loneliness.
The important point is that human beings are social creatures.
We need meaningful relationships.
We need belonging.
We need to feel that somebody knows us.
We need people we can turn to when life becomes difficult.
And men are not exempt from these needs simply because they have been taught to manage their difficulties independently.
Consider a man who has spent 20 years building a successful career.
He earns good money, owns a property, drives a nice car and appears to have everything together.
But he has no meaningful friendships.
He rarely discusses his feelings.
He does not know how to ask for help.
His relationship with his children is distant.
His marriage is deteriorating.
He spends most of his time working, watching television or scrolling through his phone.
From the outside, he might appear successful.
But psychologically, he could be experiencing profound loneliness.
This is one of the difficulties with measuring men’s wellbeing exclusively through external indicators.
We often ask:
“Are you working?”
“Are you earning?”
“Have you bought a house?”
“Are you successful?”
“Are you providing for your family?”
We do not always ask:
“Who knows you?”
“Who can you call when life becomes difficult?”
“Who do you feel safe being yourself around?”
“When was the last time you felt genuinely connected to somebody?”
“Do you feel emotionally fulfilled?”
These questions matter.
And if you are a young man, it is worth considering what kind of life you are actually building.
You can spend 20 years becoming financially successful and still arrive at 45 without the emotional relationships that make success meaningful.
The importance of teaching boys emotional literacy before they enter relationships
If we want healthier adult relationships, we need to start much earlier.
We cannot wait until a man is 35, his marriage is falling apart and his wife is considering divorce before teaching him how to communicate.
We need to teach boys emotional literacy while they are still developing their understanding of themselves.
Emotional literacy is the ability to recognise, understand, communicate and respond appropriately to emotions.
It involves more than knowing the words happy, sad and angry.
It means being able to identify the emotional experiences underneath our behaviour.
For example, a teenage boy might become aggressive after being rejected by a girl.
He might describe himself as angry.
But underneath the anger, he could be experiencing:
- Embarrassment because he feels rejected.
- Shame because he believes rejection means he is unattractive.
- Fear because he worries that nobody will want him.
- Sadness because he genuinely liked the girl.
- Jealousy because she is interested in somebody else.
- Disappointment because the relationship did not develop as he hoped.
If he only recognises anger, he might respond with hostility, insults or withdrawal.
If he develops the ability to recognise the emotions underneath the anger, he has more choices.
He can acknowledge the rejection without attacking somebody.
He can feel disappointed without becoming resentful.
He can accept that somebody is not interested without concluding that his life is over.
This is emotional maturity.
And it is something that can be learned.
Ten emotional skills every young man should develop
1
Identify what you are feeling
Learn to distinguish between anger, embarrassment, sadness, shame, anxiety, jealousy, loneliness and disappointment.
2
Communicate without attacking
Explain what is happening internally without blaming, insulting or intimidating somebody else.
3
Listen without immediately defending yourself
Allow somebody to finish explaining their experience before preparing your response.
4
Take responsibility
Recognise when your behaviour has caused harm without making the conversation entirely about your intentions.
5
Tolerate discomfort
Learn that difficult conversations, embarrassment and temporary emotional discomfort are not emergencies.
6
Ask for help
Understand that seeking support is a form of self-responsibility, not weakness.
7
Respect boundaries
Accept that other people have the right to say no, disagree and make independent decisions.
8
Develop healthy friendships
Build relationships where you can discuss more than football, work, drinking, sex and entertainment.
9
Recognise your defensive patterns
Notice when you use silence, humour, anger, withdrawal or blame to avoid emotional exposure.
10
Develop emotional intimacy
Practise allowing people you trust to understand your thoughts, fears, experiences and needs.
These skills are not simply useful for marriage.
They are useful for friendships, parenting, professional relationships, leadership and your relationship with yourself.
What this means for dating and relationships in Reading today
I want to bring this closer to home because these conversations are not confined to academic psychology or couples attending therapy after 25 years of marriage.
They are happening in Reading, Woodley, Tilehurst, Caversham, Earley, Wokingham and across the surrounding towns.
Young men are trying to understand dating, sex, relationships, commitment and what women actually expect from them.
Some are navigating their first serious relationships.
Others are trying to understand why previous relationships ended.
Some are using dating applications and struggling with rejection.
Others are becoming fathers, entering long-term partnerships or trying to establish relationships after difficult childhood experiences.
And many are trying to work out what being a man actually means in a culture where traditional expectations are being questioned.
There are a few things I think young men need to understand.
First: A woman wanting emotional intimacy does not mean she wants you to become her therapist
This is an important distinction.
You are not responsible for managing every emotion your partner experiences.
You do not need to solve all her problems.
You do not need to agree with everything she says.
You do not need to abandon your own needs.
However, being in a relationship means being willing to understand another person’s emotional experience.
Sometimes your partner does not want a solution.
She wants to feel heard.
She might tell you that she has had a difficult day at work.
Your immediate response might be to offer practical advice.
“Why don’t you just speak to your manager?”
“Why don’t you look for another job?”
“Why do you let them treat you like that?”
These might be perfectly reasonable suggestions.
But sometimes she simply wants you to say:
“That sounds really frustrating. I can understand why you’re upset. Do you want to tell me what happened?”
You have not surrendered your masculinity.
You have demonstrated that you are emotionally present.
Second: Stop assuming that paying for things is the same as showing affection
You might buy your girlfriend flowers, pay for dinner, take her on holiday and purchase expensive presents.
These things can be thoughtful expressions of love.
But they do not replace emotional connection.
Somebody can appreciate what you provide and still feel emotionally neglected.
Ask yourself whether you are investing in the relationship or simply investing money into the relationship.
They are not interchangeable.
Third: Do not punish somebody for telling you how they feel
If your partner tells you that something has upset her, try not to turn the conversation into an argument about whether she should feel that way.
You might disagree with her interpretation.
You might have a different memory of the event.
You might believe that she has misunderstood your intentions.
But you can acknowledge her experience without automatically agreeing with every conclusion.
For example: “I didn’t intend to make you feel like that, but I can see that it has affected you. Can you help me understand what was most upsetting?”
That is a much more productive starting point than: “You’re always making an issue out of nothing.”
Fourth: Learn to recognise the difference between independence and emotional avoidance
Being independent is healthy.
Having your own friends, ambitions, interests and identity is important.
But if you cannot ask somebody for support, cannot communicate your needs and cannot tolerate emotional closeness, it might be worth examining whether your independence has become a protective wall.
You can be independent and still be emotionally connected.
You can be strong and still need reassurance.
You can be ambitious and still want affection.
You can be a man and still need somebody to hold you when life becomes difficult.
Fifth: Do not expect women to carry the entire emotional responsibility of the relationship
If you want a meaningful relationship, you need to contribute to creating one.
Do not wait for your partner to initiate every difficult conversation.
Do not wait until she becomes upset before asking how she is.
Do not wait until the relationship is deteriorating before suggesting that you spend time together.
Do not assume that because she has stopped complaining, everything is fine.
Sometimes people stop raising issues because they have become exhausted by repeatedly raising them.
A healthy relationship requires two people who are willing to participate.
The therapeutic perspective: Understanding the patterns beneath the behaviour
From a counselling perspective, I think this opens up several important areas of exploration.
The first is attachment.
Our early relationships can influence how we understand closeness, dependence, separation and emotional safety.
A child who experiences inconsistent caregiving might become particularly sensitive to rejection.
A child who experiences emotional unavailability might learn to minimise their needs.
A child who experiences criticism whenever they express distress might develop strategies of withdrawal, compliance or defensiveness.
These experiences do not automatically produce a particular attachment style, and attachment should never be used as a simplistic label for somebody’s personality.
However, attachment theory can help us explore why people respond differently when relationships become emotionally demanding.
Consider a man who withdraws whenever his partner raises a difficult issue.
We could simply describe him as emotionally unavailable.
But a therapist might want to explore more deeply.
What happens inside him when somebody expresses disappointment?
Does he experience criticism as rejection?
Does he associate emotional exposure with humiliation?
Was vulnerability welcomed in his childhood?
What happened when he cried?
How did the adults around him respond to his emotional needs?
Did he learn that affection was conditional upon achievement or good behaviour?
What does he believe will happen if he allows somebody to see his insecurities?
These questions help us move beyond simply identifying problematic behaviour.
They allow us to understand the psychological function of that behaviour.
The psychodynamic perspective
From a psychodynamic perspective, some of our adult relationship patterns can be understood in relation to earlier emotional experiences and internalised relationships.
For example, a man who grew up with a highly critical father might become particularly sensitive to criticism from his partner.
His partner might say something relatively ordinary:
“Could you help me with the children this evening?”
But he experiences the request through an older emotional framework.
He might feel inadequate, controlled or criticised.
The present interaction has activated something from the past.
This does not mean that his partner is behaving like his father.
It means that his internal experience of the interaction might be influenced by earlier relationships.
Therapy can provide an opportunity to recognise these connections and develop different ways of responding.
The humanistic perspective
From a humanistic perspective, we might explore the gap between the person a man believes he needs to be and the person he actually experiences himself to be.
He might have an idealised image of masculinity.
He should always be strong.
He should never need reassurance.
He should always be successful.
He should never show fear.
He should never be rejected.
But his actual experience is considerably more complicated.
He feels lonely.
He worries about money.
He struggles with confidence.
He misses his children.
He wants affection.
He sometimes feels frightened.
The greater the gap between his actual experience and the identity he believes he must maintain, the more difficult it can become to live authentically.
A humanistic approach might help him develop greater self-acceptance and the confidence to recognise his experiences without immediately judging himself.
The cognitive behavioural perspective
From a CBT perspective, we might explore the beliefs that maintain emotional avoidance.
For example:
- If I cry, people will think I am weak.
- If I admit I am struggling, people will lose respect for me.
- If my partner criticises me, it means I am a failure.
- If I cannot solve a problem, I am useless.
- If somebody rejects me, it means I am unlovable.
- If I show vulnerability, somebody will use it against me.
These beliefs can influence emotional responses and behaviour.
A man might avoid difficult conversations because he predicts that they will end in humiliation.
He might become defensive because he interprets feedback as evidence that he is inadequate.
He might withdraw because he believes that expressing his needs will result in rejection.
CBT can help him identify these beliefs, examine the evidence and develop more balanced alternatives.
For example:
“I can make mistakes without being a failure.”
“Somebody disagreeing with me does not mean they do not respect me.”
“Vulnerability involves risk, but it can also create connection.”
“I can listen to criticism without automatically accepting that everything being said about me is true.”
“I can be emotionally honest and still maintain my boundaries.”
These are not simply positive affirmations.
They are alternative ways of interpreting experiences that might otherwise trigger defensive behaviour.
The relational perspective
Finally, we need to recognise that relationships are not built by one person changing independently.
If a couple has developed a pattern of criticism and withdrawal, both partners need opportunities to understand their contributions to that pattern.
A woman might need to explore whether her attempts to establish connection sometimes become criticism or pressure.
A man might need to explore whether his attempts to protect himself become emotional withdrawal or defensiveness.
Both might need to develop better ways of expressing their needs.
This does not mean that responsibility is always equal.
Where there is coercive control, intimidation, abuse or violence, the priority is safety and accountability. Relationship difficulties must never be used to excuse abusive behaviour or imply that a victim is responsible for another person’s abuse.
But in relationships where both people are willing to participate, understanding the pattern can be an important starting point.
A challenge for young men: What kind of man are you actually becoming?
I want to finish with something that I think deserves serious consideration.
A lot of young men spend their teenage years and early twenties trying to become the sort of man they believe other people will respect.
They want to be financially successful.
They want to be physically attractive.
They want to be sexually desirable.
They want to be confident.
They want to be respected by other men.
They want to be attractive to women.
They want to have a good career, a nice car, a property and a certain level of financial security.
There is nothing wrong with ambition.
But I think we need to ask a different question.
What are you doing to develop the person who will eventually have to maintain all those things?
Because you can build an impressive external life while remaining emotionally underdeveloped.
You can become successful professionally but struggle to maintain a healthy relationship.
You can become physically strong but remain frightened of emotional discomfort.
You can earn £80,000 a year but struggle to tell your partner that you are worried about something.
You can have thousands of followers online but have nobody you feel comfortable calling when you are struggling.
You can become a father but struggle to understand your children’s emotional needs.
You can become a husband but never really learn how to be emotionally intimate with your wife.
And these are things worth thinking about before you reach a point where your relationship, mental health or family life begins to suffer.
I would encourage every young man to consider the following questions.
About your childhood
- What did the men in your family teach you about being a man?
- Were you allowed to cry when you were growing up?
- How did your father or other male role models respond when you were upset?
- Did you feel that you could talk openly about your fears?
- Did you learn that being independent meant never asking for help?
About your relationships
- When somebody tells you that you have hurt them, what is your immediate reaction?
- Do you listen to understand, or do you listen to defend yourself?
- Are you comfortable telling somebody when you feel lonely, insecure or frightened?
- Do you know how to apologise without making excuses?
- Do the people closest to you actually know what is going on inside you?
About your masculinity
- Do you believe that vulnerability makes a man weak?
- Are you comfortable being affectionate with your male friends?
- Can you acknowledge when another man is better than you at something?
- Do you feel that you always need to be in control?
- Are you building an identity around who you genuinely are, or around what you believe a man is supposed to be?
These are not questions designed to make men feel inadequate.
They are questions designed to help men develop self-awareness.
Because if you cannot examine the beliefs you have inherited, you might spend your entire adult life repeating patterns you never consciously chose.
Final thoughts: We do not need to raise stronger boys. We need to raise more emotionally connected men.
I challenge the idea that the answer to men’s difficulties is simply to tell them to become more sensitive, communicate more and stop being emotionally unavailable.
We need to understand where these difficulties come from.
Many boys have been raised in environments where emotional vulnerability was discouraged. They have learned to associate masculinity with invulnerability, independence and emotional control.
Some have experienced absent fathers. Others have grown up with emotionally unavailable fathers. Some have experienced criticism, bullying, rejection or environments where showing emotion was not considered safe.
Some have had positive male role models but have still absorbed wider cultural messages about what it means to be a man.
These experiences matter.
But understanding the origins of a behaviour does not mean we have to remain trapped by it.
You can acknowledge that your father never taught you how to communicate without accepting that you must repeat his behaviour.
You can recognise that you were discouraged from crying without deciding that you must remain emotionally closed.
You can understand why criticism makes you defensive without making your partner responsible for managing your reactions.
You can recognise that relationships are difficult without concluding that women are asking for too much.
And you can become a different kind of man without feeling that you have betrayed the men who came before you.
I think this is where the conversation about masculinity needs to move.
Not towards telling men that everything traditionally associated with masculinity is wrong.
But towards helping men distinguish between the qualities that genuinely serve them and the behaviours that leave them emotionally isolated.
Strength is useful.
Independence is useful.
Discipline is useful.
Ambition is useful.
Responsibility is useful.
But none of these qualities require emotional disconnection.
You can be disciplined and emotionally expressive.
You can be ambitious and affectionate.
You can be independent and still ask for support.
You can be strong and admit that you are struggling.
You can be a provider and an emotionally present father.
You can be a husband who takes responsibility without feeling that every disagreement is an attack on his masculinity.
And perhaps most importantly, you can be a man who knows how to love somebody without expecting them to do all the emotional work.
I would like young men to understand that the purpose of developing emotional intelligence is not simply to become more attractive to women or to prevent a relationship from ending.
It is to become more psychologically developed as a human being.
It is about being able to experience the full range of human emotions without being frightened of yourself.
It is about having friendships where you can be honest.
It is about building relationships where you do not have to pretend.
It is about becoming a father who can comfort his son and reassure his daughter.
It is about being able to recognise when you are wrong, apologise and change.
It is about developing a relationship with yourself that does not depend entirely upon how much money you earn, how successful you become or how other people perceive you.
And it is about recognising that the boy you once were might still be influencing the man you are today.
Perhaps he learned not to cry.
Perhaps he learned not to ask for help.
Perhaps he learned to hide his disappointment.
Perhaps he learned to turn sadness into anger.
Perhaps he learned that being loved depended upon being good, successful or useful.
Perhaps nobody ever taught him that he could be vulnerable and still be worthy of love.
That boy deserves some attention.
Not because he needs to be rescued from masculinity, but because he deserves the opportunity to develop beyond the limitations that might have been placed upon him.
The disconnected boy does not have to become the disconnected man.
And if we want healthier relationships, healthier families and healthier communities, perhaps one of the most important things we can do is teach our boys that they do not have to abandon their emotional worlds to become men.
They can bring their whole selves with them.
That, in my view, is a much healthier understanding of masculinity.
Further reading: The psychological thinkers behind this conversation
For young men, parents, counsellors and anybody interested in understanding the relationship between masculinity, emotional development and intimacy, these are some useful starting points.
- Carol Gilligan – In a Different Voice
- Terry Real – I Don’t Want to Talk About It
- Terry Real – Us: Getting Past You and Me to Build a More Loving Relationship
- bell hooks – The Will to Change: Men, Masculinity, and Love
- Brené Brown – Daring Greatly
- John Bowlby – A Secure Base
- Sue Johnson – Hold Me Tight
- David Schnarch – Passionate Marriage
- Robert Bly – Iron John
- Terrence Real – The New Rules of Marriage
Male Minds Counselling
For boys and men in Reading and Berkshire, understanding yourself emotionally is not a weakness. It is an important part of developing healthier relationships, stronger friendships and a more secure sense of who you are.
If you find yourself struggling with emotional expression, relationship difficulties, anger, anxiety, loneliness, self-esteem or the impact of childhood experiences, counselling can provide a space to explore these patterns without judgement.
Male Minds Counselling – Supporting boys and men to understand themselves, their relationships and their emotional wellbeing.
Website: malemindscounselling.com
Substack: cassimkaweesa.substack.com
