Does Therapy Even Work? What Talking About Your Feelings Can Actually Change in a Man’s Life

“Does therapy even work?” Is a question I was asked recently by someone who wanted to know what I did for a living. I explained that, alongside my other work, I run a counselling practice where I work predominantly with boys and men. The individual struggled to understand how sitting in a room and talking about your feelings could actually change anything in your life.

It was a fair question, and one worth exploring. If you have spent most of your life believing that problems are solved by taking action, working harder, earning more money, becoming more disciplined or finding practical solutions, then the idea that talking to another person might make a meaningful difference can seem difficult to understand.

But there is something important that I wanted this young man to consider: not every problem can be solved by doing something. Some things need to be understood.

And not every meaningful transformation is visible to the outside world. Sometimes the most significant change happens internally, in the way we understand ourselves, interpret other people, experience our emotions, make sense of our past and relate to the world around us.

First, does therapy actually work?

The short answer is yes. There is substantial research evidence that psychological therapies can help people experiencing difficulties such as anxiety, depression, trauma-related symptoms and relationship problems. However, I think it is important to be honest about what that means. Therapy is not a magic solution, it does not work in exactly the same way for everybody, and it cannot undo everything that has happened to someone.

The question is not simply whether therapy works. It is also worth asking: what do we mean by working?

For one person, success might mean no longer experiencing panic attacks. For another, it might mean being able to speak to their partner without becoming defensive, understanding why they repeatedly choose emotionally unavailable relationships, or learning to recognise anger before it turns into an argument. For somebody else, therapy might mean finally being able to talk about something that happened in childhood without feeling overwhelmed by shame.

These are different outcomes, but they can all represent meaningful change.

NHS England’s latest annual figures for 2025–26 report that 50.1% of referrals completing a course of NHS Talking Therapies moved to recovery. That is an important indication that psychological treatment can make a measurable difference, although it also reminds us that recovery is not the outcome for everybody. The figures relate to a particular service, population and set of measures. They should not be interpreted as a guarantee of what will happen in an individual person’s therapy.

And this brings me to an important distinction: sometimes the aim of therapy is to reduce symptoms, but sometimes it is to help someone understand the experiences, beliefs and relationships that have shaped the way they live.

You might not be able to change what happened to you. You may not be able to change your family, your childhood, the decisions somebody else made or the opportunities you were denied. But you may be able to change the way you understand those experiences, the meaning you have attached to them and the way you respond to them now.

I often think about a quote attributed to Jim Rohn: you cannot change your destination overnight, but you can change your direction. I think there is something useful in that idea. Change does not always begin with a dramatic external achievement. Sometimes it begins with a different understanding of yourself.

Your perspective is not the only perspective

One of the things I have come to recognise through working with people is that we can become so familiar with our own perspective that we mistake it for reality itself.

We interpret a conversation, a disagreement, a relationship or an experience from the position we occupy. We know what we intended to say, what we felt, what we feared and what we believed was happening. But we do not automatically know what was happening inside the other person.

For example, a man might come home from work and find that his partner is upset because he has barely spoken to her all evening. His interpretation might be that she is being unreasonable because he has had a difficult day and simply wants some peace. Her interpretation might be that he is emotionally unavailable and that she has spent another evening feeling alone.

Both people are experiencing the same relationship, but they are not necessarily experiencing it in the same way.

This is where the psychological concept of mentalisation becomes important. Mentalisation is the capacity to understand our own behaviour and the behaviour of others in terms of underlying mental states, including feelings, thoughts, intentions, needs and desires. In simpler language, it is the ability to think about what might be happening inside ourselves and inside another person.

It allows us to move beyond assuming that we know what somebody else thinks or feels. It also helps us become curious about our own reactions. Why did that comment make me so angry? Why did I interpret their silence as rejection? Why did I withdraw when what I actually wanted was reassurance?

A 2024 systematic review by Luyten and colleagues examined the role of mentalisation in psychological interventions. The authors suggested that mentalising may be one of the processes involved in therapeutic change, although they also highlighted limitations in the available evidence and the need for further research.

This matters because being intelligent, educated, successful or productive does not automatically mean that we are skilled at understanding ourselves or navigating relationships.

A man might be excellent at managing a business, solving practical problems, earning money and organising his life, but still struggle to recognise when he is frightened, ashamed, lonely or emotionally overwhelmed. He might be able to explain what happened in an argument but have very little understanding of what was happening emotionally for either person.

We can become highly competent in some areas of life while remaining underdeveloped in others.

Therapy can provide a place to begin developing that understanding.

Have we confused being a man with disconnecting from ourselves?

I think this is particularly important when we talk about boys and men.

We live within social systems that have historically associated masculinity with strength, independence, control, toughness, authority and the ability to provide. These expectations do not affect every man in the same way, and men do not all experience masculinity identically. But they can influence what boys are taught to value, what emotions they feel permitted to express and how they learn to understand themselves.

Consider some of the messages boys may encounter as they grow up.

Do not cry. Do not be weak. Do not let anybody disrespect you. Be a provider. Be independent. Do not need anybody. Sort your problems out. Keep your emotions under control. Be successful. Be a man.

Some of these messages may be intended to prepare boys for the difficulties of adult life. But what happens when a boy learns that expressing sadness makes him weak? What happens when he learns to interpret vulnerability as humiliation? What happens when he becomes so accustomed to suppressing his feelings that he eventually struggles to identify what he is feeling in the first place?

He may become very good at functioning while knowing very little about how he is actually doing.

This is one of the reasons I think it is important to examine the relationship between masculinity, emotional development and mental health. In The Will to Change, bell hooks explores how patriarchal expectations can restrict men’s emotional lives and their capacity for love. Her argument is not that men are naturally emotionally disconnected. Rather, she challenges the social expectations that can teach boys to suppress vulnerability and associate emotional openness with weakness.

This is an important distinction. We should not assume that every man’s difficulty with emotions comes from patriarchy, or that all men have the same experience. Family culture, childhood experiences, trauma, poverty, racism, religion, disability, neurodivergence and individual temperament can all influence emotional development.

But it is worth asking men what they have been taught about being a man, and whether those lessons are still serving them.

Sometimes therapy involves examining beliefs that a person has never previously questioned. Not because the counsellor wants to tell them how to live, but because the person deserves the opportunity to decide which beliefs they want to continue carrying.

Sometimes you need somebody else to help you understand your story

Another thing I explained to the young man is that many people have never really had the opportunity to tell their story.

They may have spoken about individual events, perhaps mentioned something that happened during childhood or described a difficult relationship. But that is not necessarily the same as having the opportunity to explore their life as a whole, understand how different experiences connect and consider the conclusions they have drawn about themselves.

I think this is where narrative approaches to therapy offer something particularly valuable.

Narrative therapy, associated with the work of Michael White and David Epston, explores the stories people develop about themselves and their lives. These stories influence how we understand our identity, our relationships and what we believe is possible for our future.

For example, somebody might come into counselling believing that they are the problem in every relationship. They might describe themselves as difficult, unlovable, selfish or broken. They may have spent years interpreting their experiences through that particular understanding of themselves.

But where did that story come from?

Perhaps they grew up in a household where they were repeatedly blamed for family difficulties. Perhaps they were made responsible for keeping the peace between their parents. Perhaps they were bullied, rejected or emotionally neglected. Perhaps they experienced a relationship in which another person consistently made them feel inadequate.

Over time, these experiences may have contributed to a deeply held belief: There must be something wrong with me.

Narrative approaches invite us to examine that conclusion rather than automatically accepting it as the truth.

This is sometimes described as separating the person from the problem. Instead of treating someone as though they are their anxiety, their anger, their addiction or their shame, the therapist helps them explore how these difficulties have influenced their life.

The question changes from, “What is wrong with me?” to, “What has happened in my life, what have I learnt to believe about myself, and how has this problem been influencing the way I live?”

That distinction can be significant.

It does not mean that we avoid personal responsibility. It means that we develop a more accurate understanding of responsibility. There is a difference between taking responsibility for something you have done and accepting responsibility for everything that has happened to you.

You can take responsibility for your life without taking responsibility for somebody else’s behaviour.

Are you carrying things that were never yours to carry?

This leads me to another concept that I think deserves much more attention, particularly when working with men: parentification.

Parentification occurs when a child is placed in a role that involves responsibilities normally expected of a parent or another adult. This might involve providing emotional support to a parent, looking after younger siblings in ways that exceed ordinary expectations, managing adult problems or becoming the person who keeps the family functioning.

There is a difference between children having age-appropriate responsibilities and being placed in a position where they have to take care of the emotional or practical needs of the adults around them.

Imagine a boy who grows up with a mother who is emotionally distressed. He learns that he must not upset her, that he needs to be the sensible one and that his own problems can wait. He becomes the person who listens, reassures and tries to keep everything together.

As an adult, he might be extremely independent. He might struggle to ask for help, feel uncomfortable receiving care and become attracted to relationships in which he is needed by somebody else.

He may even believe that his value comes from how useful he is to other people.

But where did he learn that?

This is the kind of question that can be explored in counselling. We might look at childhood experiences, family roles, attachment patterns and the beliefs that developed around responsibility, love and worth.

Perhaps the man is not simply independent. Perhaps independence became a way of surviving an environment in which he could not rely on others.

Perhaps he is not naturally uncomfortable with vulnerability. Perhaps he learnt that showing vulnerability would create more problems for the people around him.

Perhaps he does not know how to receive care because he spent much of his childhood providing it.

These are not conclusions a counsellor should impose on somebody. They are possibilities to explore collaboratively, based on the person’s actual experiences.

The point is that our current behaviour often makes more sense when we understand the context in which it developed.

Sometimes what you need is information

Another important part of counselling is psychoeducation.

Psychoeducation simply means helping someone understand psychological concepts, emotional processes and patterns of behaviour that might be relevant to their experiences.

Sometimes people have spent years struggling with something without having the language to describe it.

They might not understand what anxiety is doing in their body. They might not recognise the relationship between their thoughts, feelings and behaviours. They might not understand attachment, emotional regulation, trauma responses, boundaries, shame or the effects of chronic stress.

They may have been labelled difficult, lazy, aggressive, overly sensitive or unreliable without anybody helping them understand what might be happening underneath those behaviours.

For example, somebody who struggles with executive functioning might interpret their difficulties as evidence that they are lazy or undisciplined. If they have ADHD, some of those difficulties may be associated with differences in attention regulation, planning, organisation and task initiation.

A counsellor or psychotherapist who is appropriately trained can help someone explore these experiences, consider whether neurodivergence might be relevant and discuss whether a formal assessment would be useful. Counselling itself does not automatically establish an ADHD diagnosis, and a counsellor should be clear about the limits of their professional role.

But simply having the language to understand an experience can change how somebody relates to themselves.

There is a difference between believing, “I am useless because I cannot organise my life,” and beginning to understand, “I seem to have persistent difficulties with planning and task initiation. I need to understand what is contributing to this and what support might help.”

The difficulty has not necessarily disappeared. But the person’s relationship with the difficulty may have changed.

They can move away from shame and towards understanding, appropriate support and practical strategies.

This is one of the reasons I believe information matters. We cannot expect people to understand experiences they have never been given the opportunity to learn about.

But why can’t you just read a book or watch YouTube?

This was another point I wanted the young man to consider.

We have access to an extraordinary amount of psychological information. You can read books about attachment, watch videos about childhood trauma, listen to podcasts about masculinity, study emotional regulation and learn about cognitive behavioural therapy.

These resources can be incredibly useful. I actively encourage people to read, study and become curious about their own lives.

But information and personal transformation are not necessarily the same thing.

You can understand the theory of attachment and still find yourself repeatedly pursuing relationships with people who are emotionally unavailable. You can know that you have an anxious response to rejection and still experience overwhelming anxiety when somebody does not reply to your message. You can understand the importance of boundaries and still struggle to say no to your parents.

Knowing something intellectually does not always mean that we can put it into practice emotionally.

This is where the therapeutic relationship becomes important.

In psychotherapy, the relationship between the client and therapist is not simply a convenient arrangement that allows somebody to talk. It can become an important part of the therapeutic process itself.

A person might have spent their life expecting criticism, rejection, judgement or abandonment. They may have learnt to hide certain parts of themselves because previous relationships did not feel emotionally safe.

In therapy, they have an opportunity to experience a different kind of relationship. One in which they can explore difficult experiences, express feelings, disagree, ask questions and examine parts of themselves they may previously have felt unable to share.

This is sometimes discussed through the idea of a reparative or corrective emotional experience. The relationship can provide an opportunity to experience something different from familiar relational patterns.

For example, a man who expects every disagreement to end in rejection might become anxious when he disagrees with his therapist. He may worry that he has said something wrong or that the therapist will think less of him.

Rather than simply reassuring him, the therapist might help him explore what is happening. What does disagreement mean to him? What does he imagine will happen next? Where has he experienced this before?

Over time, he may discover that disagreement does not automatically lead to rejection. He can express a different opinion and remain in a relationship.

That experience may become meaningful beyond the counselling room.

It is important to say that a therapist is not a replacement parent, partner or friend. The therapeutic relationship has professional boundaries, and the work is not about creating dependence on the counsellor. It is about helping someone develop greater understanding, emotional capacity and healthier ways of relating.

Research into psychotherapy has consistently highlighted the importance of the therapeutic alliance: the collaborative relationship between client and therapist, including agreement about the work and the goals being pursued. The relationship is not the only factor that contributes to change, but it is an important part of how many therapies work.

Is CBT the only type of therapy that works?

When people think about counselling in the UK, they may think about Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, commonly known as CBT.

There is a reason for that. CBT has a substantial research evidence base and is widely used within NHS Talking Therapies.

According to NHS England’s 2025–26 figures, CBT accounted for 42.3% of all courses of therapy delivered through the programme. CBT and guided self-help using books together accounted for 71% of courses.

CBT can be extremely helpful. It explores the relationships between thoughts, emotions, physical sensations and behaviours. It can help people identify unhelpful thinking patterns, understand how avoidance maintains anxiety and develop practical ways of responding differently.

For example, somebody who experiences panic attacks might interpret a racing heart as evidence that they are having a heart attack. That interpretation increases their fear, which can intensify their physical sensations. CBT can help them understand this cycle and develop alternative ways of interpreting and responding to those sensations.

However, I think it is important that we do not reduce the entire purpose of psychotherapy to changing behaviour.

Changing behaviour can be valuable, but behaviour is only one part of a person’s experience.

A man might learn to manage his anger more effectively but still have very little understanding of the shame, rejection or helplessness that sits underneath it. He might learn to challenge negative thoughts but still struggle with a deep sense of unworthiness. He might become more productive while remaining emotionally disconnected from the people he loves.

That does not mean CBT has failed. It may mean that the person has achieved something important, but there are other aspects of their experience that they want to explore.

Different therapeutic approaches offer different ways of understanding psychological difficulties.

Psychodynamic therapy might explore unconscious processes, early relationships, defences and recurring patterns.

Person-centred therapy places importance on empathy, acceptance, authenticity and creating the conditions in which someone can explore their experiences without feeling judged.

Transactional Analysis can help people understand recurring patterns in relationships, including the roles they adopt and the ways they communicate.

Existential approaches might explore questions of identity, freedom, responsibility, meaning, isolation and what it means to live authentically.

Narrative therapy can help people examine the stories they have developed about themselves and consider alternative ways of understanding their lives.

These approaches are not interchangeable, and they do not all have the same evidence base for every difficulty. The important point is that psychological therapy is not one single activity. There are different models, methods and ways of working, and the suitability of an approach depends on the person, their needs and the difficulties they want to address.

Some things need to change emotionally, not just practically

I want to return to something I mentioned earlier: not every transformation is visible.

Imagine a man who has spent years believing that he must achieve something significant before he deserves to feel proud of himself.

He works hard, earns money, builds a career and reaches the goals he has set. But every achievement provides only temporary relief. Before long, he is looking for the next thing.

He might describe himself as ambitious, but underneath that ambition there may also be a fear of being ordinary, a fear of failure or a belief that he is only valuable when he is achieving something.

There is nothing inherently wrong with ambition. Wanting to build a successful life is not a psychological problem. But what happens when somebody cannot enjoy what they have achieved because they are constantly trying to prove that they are enough?

Therapy might help this person explore where that belief originated, what purpose it serves and what it costs him.

The change may not be that he stops working hard. It may be that he no longer needs to use achievement as the only way of establishing his worth.

Another man might come into therapy because his relationship has ended. Initially, he may want to understand how to get his former partner back. But as the work develops, he begins to recognise patterns in how he responds to intimacy, conflict and emotional vulnerability.

He starts to understand that he often withdraws when relationships become emotionally demanding. He recognises that he struggles to communicate his needs and that he sometimes interprets ordinary disagreement as criticism.

The relationship may still end. Therapy cannot guarantee reconciliation. But he may leave with a better understanding of himself and a greater capacity to build healthier relationships in the future.

This is still change.

Sometimes the external circumstances do not change in the way we hoped. What changes is our capacity to understand, tolerate and respond to them.

What about the things that cannot be fixed?

I think this is one of the most important parts of the conversation.

Therapy cannot bring back somebody who has died. It cannot give you the childhood you did not have. It cannot make an absent parent become present, undo abuse or guarantee that somebody will apologise for the way they treated you.

There are experiences that cannot be reversed.

And sometimes the work is not about fixing the past. It is about understanding how the past continues to influence the present.

Grief is a good example. A person who has lost somebody they love may not need to be taught how to stop grieving. They may need somewhere to talk about the person they have lost, make sense of their feelings, acknowledge what the relationship meant and find a way to continue living while carrying that loss.

Similarly, somebody who experienced childhood neglect may not need to be told to think positively. They may need to recognise that their emotional needs mattered, that the responsibility for meeting those needs did not belong to them as a child and that their experiences were not evidence of their lack of worth.

There is a difference between accepting that something happened and accepting that it should have happened.

Therapy can help people make that distinction.

So, does therapy work?

I would answer the young man’s question by saying that therapy can work, but perhaps not always in the way he imagines.

It is not simply about sitting in a room, talking about feelings and hoping that something changes. It is a process of exploration, understanding, reflection and, where appropriate, developing new ways of thinking, feeling, behaving and relating.

Sometimes the work is practical. Sometimes it is emotional. Sometimes it involves looking at childhood experiences, family relationships, masculinity, identity, culture, shame or the beliefs we have inherited from the people and environments around us.

Sometimes it involves learning something about yourself that you have never previously understood.

And sometimes it involves recognising that the way you have been living is not necessarily the way you want to continue living.

I also think men need to reconsider what they mean when they talk about strength.

If you can spend years studying how to improve your finances, build your career, develop your body, become a better employee or run a business, why would you not also invest time in understanding your emotional life and relationships?

Why should understanding yourself be considered less important than understanding the world around you?

You can be financially successful and emotionally disconnected. You can be physically strong and frightened of vulnerability. You can be intelligent and struggle to understand your own behaviour. You can be independent and desperately lonely.

These things can exist together.

And perhaps one of the most important things therapy offers is the opportunity to stop treating these contradictions as things you must hide and start understanding them as experiences you can explore.

I often encourage people to study their lives. Not simply to read books or collect information, but to become curious about the patterns they repeat, the relationships they form, the emotions they avoid and the stories they tell themselves.

Look at the films you are drawn to. Look at the characters you identify with. Look at the relationships you keep returning to. Look at the things that make you disproportionately angry, the situations that make you feel small and the moments when you find yourself behaving in ways you do not understand.

There may be something worth exploring there.

You do not have to be in crisis to benefit from understanding yourself. You do not have to wait until your relationship breaks down, your anxiety becomes unbearable or your life reaches a point where you can no longer function.

And you do not have to have all the answers before you walk into a counselling room.

Sometimes the first meaningful change is not changing your life. It is finally understanding the life you have been living.

Counselling for boys and men in Reading and Berkshire

At Male Minds Counselling, I work predominantly with boys and men, offering a space to explore emotional difficulties, relationships, identity, masculinity, anxiety, self-esteem, family experiences and the challenges of everyday life.

You do not need to arrive with a clear explanation of what is wrong. Sometimes you simply know that something is not quite right, that you keep repeating the same patterns or that you want to understand yourself better.

Counselling is available online and in person in Reading, Berkshire. I offer a free 30-minute initial Zoom assessment so that we can discuss what has brought you to counselling and whether working together might be appropriate.

If you are a man who has ever wondered whether talking to somebody could make a difference, perhaps the question is worth exploring rather than dismissing.

Visit Male Minds Counselling to find out more.

Research and reading

These are useful sources to support the themes in the article and provide further reading.

  • American Psychological Association (2013). Recognition of psychotherapy effectiveness. This provides a professional overview of evidence for psychotherapy.
  • Epston, D. and White, M. (1990). Narrative Means to Therapeutic Ends. New York: W.W. Norton.
  • hooks, b. (2004). The Will to Change: Men, Masculinity, and Love. New York: Atria Books.
  • Luyten, P., Campbell, C., Moser, M. and Fonagy, P. (2024). ‘The role of mentalizing in psychological interventions in adults: Systematic review and recommendations for future research’. Clinical Psychology Review.
  • Rogers, C.R. (1957). ‘The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change’. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 21(2), pp. 95–103.
  • Wampold, B.E. and Imel, Z.E. (2015). The Great Psychotherapy Debate: The Evidence for What Makes Psychotherapy Work. 2nd edn. New York: Routledge.
  • NHS England (2026). NHS Talking Therapies, for anxiety and depression, Annual reports, 2025–26.

Does Therapy Work? How Counselling Helps Men | Reading

Does therapy actually work? Explore the psychology behind counselling, emotional development, masculinity and how therapy can help men understand themselves.

/does-therapy-work-men-reading/

Counselling for men Reading, men’s counselling Berkshire, psychotherapy for men, benefits of counselling, therapy for men, emotional wellbeing for men, counselling Reading.

  • Panic Attacks Explained
  • CBT for Panic Attacks in Reading
  • Understanding Anxiety in Men
  • Low Self-Esteem in Men
  • Mother Wounds in Men
  • Boundaries: A Guide for Men

Book a Workplace Mental Health Workshop

Whether you're looking to support employee wellbeing, reduce workplace stress or create a psychologically safer culture, I'd be happy to discuss how these workshops can support your organisation.


Or please fill out the form with what you are looking for and when.


Email: malemindscounselling@gmail.com

Phone: 07807 344813

Website: www.malemindscounselling.com


© Copyright 2026 for Male Minds Counselling

powered by WebHealer